The thing with picking Duncan @ 5 is that most people will try and get their team's primary playmaker with the 1st pick. This is something Duncan really doesn't do anymore. However, he is probably the best player in the NBA with a usage rate under 25 from the last season. So you could take a lower-tier #1 option in the second round (plenty left) and not be at a disadvantage because you have Tim Duncan with that person. Hotttnickkk certainly didn't screw himself over with his pick, and I don't think it's as bad as I initially thought. It just seems odd to take the best complementary player available (imo) at #5 impo. It makes even more sense when you think about how much of a crapshoot it appeared to be after Lebron and Durant. Not much difference in perceived value between these players.