What's new

Carmelo Anthony Traded to the Knicks.

I know there is the whole CBA thing but Carmelo should have just gone into the summer a FA and signed with the Knicks. Now he is knick but they have no depth at all.
 
Walsh and D'Antoni are both letting it known through "sources" that this trade was all Dolan, Isiah, and Worldwide Wes.
Dumb, dumb, dumb. New York knew Carmelo wanted to play there. Only reason for giving up so much is perhaps the fear that under a new CBA, all they could have offered next season was the MLE. They gave up WAY too much. Carmelo, Amare and Billlups without much else. Not a team that can advance very far in the playoffs.
 
Okay, so Amare turns down Phoenix to go to NYC, Lebron and Bosh turn down Cleveland and Toronto to go to Miami, Carmello bolts Denver to go to NYC. How are teams like Denver, Toronto, Phoenix and Cleveland supposed to compete? Even when they get top-shelf lottery talent, they can't hold onto it because the All-Star players only want to be in one of 4 or 5 cities. See what happens with Chris Paul next year....
 
Okay, so Amare turns down Phoenix to go to NYC, Lebron and Bosh turn down Cleveland and Toronto to go to Miami, Carmello bolts Denver to go to NYC. How are teams like Denver, Toronto, Phoenix and Cleveland supposed to compete? Even when they get top-shelf lottery talent, they can't hold onto it because the All-Star players only want to be in one of 4 or 5 cities. See what happens with Chris Paul next year....


Hopefully the next CBA includes a franchise tag and a hard cap.
 
As silly as it sounds to some people, something really has to be done to quell this crap that's going on.

Its not silly at all. Small market teams in the NBA, at least from a competetive standpoint, are about to be a permanent thing of the past unless something is done quickly. I applaud the Miller's for spending what they have just to keep us as relatively competetive as we have been, but even they cannot sustain this. Without action in the next CBA, the NBA will be what MLB is. We will be the Kansas City Royals of the NBA - a once proud and competetive franchise that is relegated to just existing, nevermind competing.
 
What really sucks is Toronto is not a small market nor a crappy city. And neither is Denver. This isn't even necessarily about big vs. small, this is just getting to the point where something has to be done to try to keep parity. At the same time, guaranteed contracts destroy franchises if they're not careful and implementing a cap with more restrictions and less exceptions could make those errors exponentially more hazardous.

The NFL's CBA is a proven model for creating parity, even if it's not perfect. The closer the NBA gets to their model, the better the league will be. And maybe after a couple of franchises get contracted out (that aren't the Jazz).
 
Knicks get better, but not title contenders by any means. They did well in this, not for this year, but the future. They didn't have to give up a superstar to get one. Felton is good, but superstars like Melo and Amare are tough to come by.
 
I know there is the whole CBA thing but Carmelo should have just gone into the summer a FA and signed with the Knicks. Now he is knick but they have no depth at all.
Signing a contract now he gets to make the max money in the city he wants. NY could not offer melo the max without a sign and trade if I understand correctly.
He also avoids risking the terms of the new CBA which are likely to reduce player salaries in one way or another.
https://sports.espn.go.com/nba/columns/story?columnist=coon_larry&page=CarmeloFA-110216
 
Minnesota is the most pathetic franchise in the NBA, by far. Not only did they get involved in this trade, but they traded away Corey Brewer for Eddy Curry and Anthony Randolph. How many more terrible trades/draft picks is this organization going to make?

Granted Corey Brewer wasn't anything special to begin with, why in the hell would they take on Eddy Curry's ***?
 
Back
Top