In no way was I making a line-by-line comparison of Fes to Ostertag. The point was that some players have the physical tools to succeed, but aren't able to use them on a consistent basis.
Exactly. And when a player--especially a big--is averaging well less than 10 MPG, even when he shows signs of progress, then it is unlikely that they will be able to develop that consistency. For most players, superstar and backup alike, there is no substitute for going through the experience on center court.
I've always thought Fes needed more playing time, but he also was a very unreliable player - from being a foul machine when he was on the court to missing games for gastric distress and sinus issues - I do understand why Sloan and Corbin were reluctant to play him more.
However, when Fes was on the court, the team held serve or even advanced the lead/reduced the deficit more often than not. Is anybody claiming that he should've played 20 or 25 or 30 MPG? No; both his foul rate and the coaches' lack of attention to his development were both core barriers to that. But too often, the coaches settled for status quo (not just at the C spot, btw) instead of enforcing effort and performance.
The illness problems this year accounted for about a dozen DNPs this year, and that's a strike against him (that might start becoming a bigger issue in the future). Fes's effort (and sometimes behavior) off the court did himself no service, either. But neither of these trends account for him not receiving playing time when he was healthy and contributing.
He did make a positive impact in several of his appearances last season but he was also a complete non-factor in just as many others. As a Jazz fan I'd like him to stay but for Fes' sake a change of scenery might be the best thing for his career.
As a Jazz fan, I don't care about "Fes' sake" as much as the team's sake.
If Kanter has anywhere near the potential of a typical #3 draft pick, then Fes is definitely expendable now. Unfortunately, he's the latest exhibit of a string of crucial backups (not just at the 5) that the Jazz were unsuccessful at developing (including the carefully selected crucial court time). Here's hoping that the Jazz staff does better with the new young bigs and wings.