I'd take Hibbert. I just worry about him if the NBA starts moving more and more towards the Fred Hoiberg offensive system. Really limits his impact on defense if everyone on the other team can shoot and drive. He's pretty slow. He would have to be effective enough on the offensive end to counter-act such an approach.
And I agree with fish, I just flat out don't like watching him play.
Didn't know Hoiberg invented that offensive system.