Kings/Hawks - Instant Replay, give me your opinion

[Dr. Jones]

It was a question about if a player's hand was hit causing the ball to go out of band, whether it'd be on the player or the hitter. I gave the answer by quoting the NBA official rule book. The official rule book says it'd be on the hitter. It does not say it would be a foul. It does not say it would be on the player who touched it last. I've seen this in dozens of NBA games. The question is settled.

1) if it was understood that Rondo had hit the hand of Milsap then I acquiesce. I missed that part of the explanation.
2) no. I say when things are settled, not unicorn petters.

 

[Siro]

1) if it was understood that Rondo had hit the hand of Milsap then I acquiesce. I missed that part of the explanation.
2) no. I say when things are settled, not unicorn petters.

I was adding to the conversation between GF and others as it applies to the general rule. I am not giving an opinion on this specific play.

Also, enough with your unicorn hate. They are people too.

 

[Dr. Jones]

I was adding to the conversation between GF and others as it applies to the general rule. I am not giving an opinion on this specific play.

Also, enough with your unicorn hate. They are people too.

Lol

 

[Gameface]

Are you guys serious? It's who touched it last period. How the **** can you possibly think it's dependent on the aggressor rather than last touched. That's some silly silly ****.

haha

and you sounded so sure...

 

[Dr. Jones]

haha

and you sounded so sure...

I still am.

 

[Gameface]

I still am.

Okay, cool.