When I tell you, you're initial reaction will be, "you are ruhtard." You have to think back to get some context though.
Cam Newton was ranked by ESPN as the 29th rated fantasy QB going into 2011 and went undrafted in almost every league. His first game he tore it up, but almost every "expert" said that it was because of Arizona's weak secondary and that he likely wouldn't have another passing game like that the rest of his career, let alone during his first season.
I picked him up on the waiver wire after the first week specifically to trade him to a girl in my league who is a huge Panthers fan. I traded him for Dwayne Bowe, who the year before had ended the season as the 2nd highest scoring WR. I had Phillip Rivers, and its hard to imagine now, but at the time I couldn't see myself ever starting Cam over Rivers.
I honestly thought I had made a killer trade at the time, and possibly even ripped the girl off. Instead, Bowe had a bad year, Rivers had the worst fantasy year of his career, and Cam tore up the league. The girl I made the trade with ended up winning the league ($50 buy in) and I haven't heard the end of it since.