I agree with most of this, although I haven't seen plays like this get overturned personally. I've seen other examples of the opposite though.And that is why they never call a foul in that scenario.
All of a sudden in this one game in this instance they are going to go by “the rule book” instead of the actual way they always call the play?
Thats ********. Call should have stood and I bet it would almost every time. I was shocked they changed the call regardless of what a rule book says. I have watched a lot of basketball and have seen plays just like that one get reviewed and never overturned.
Sent from my iPad using JazzFanz mobile app
The most egregious example I can think of is the 2021 WCF Game 2, when a Suns player got the inbounds and a Clippers player batted it out of bounds. They called it Suns ball, the Clippers challenged, and on the replay you can see even though the Clippers player knocked it out of bounds, it was technically the Suns player who touched it last. During the normal course of play they ALWAYS call that out of bounds on the team knocking it out, even though pretty often that's not really the case.
Bottom line is, the rules should reflect how the officials actually call the game.