This goes back to my original post, in that the Insurance companies are the real puppet masters here. They have gamed the system, and they are the only ones who profit (literally) off all of this.
Health insurance is like a utility at this point: mature, highly competitive, and reliant on consumption growth to squeeze profit out of a low margin industry. Their angle is about bringing more onto their roles, and covering more stuff as prices get passed along.
Again, it is because the insurance companies are exempt from anti-trust laws. They can set the price and there is nothing anyone can do about it. For example, in Washington State last year, Delta Dental found out that they were covering a dental crown at $650 and Select Health was covering the same crown at $500. So what did Delta do? The raised their premiums and then told Dentists that they would only pay $550 for a crown. A clear violation of anti-trust laws, but insurance companies are exempt from anti-trust laws.
Dentists all over Washington State sent in letters to Delta Dental letting them know they would no longer be providers for Delta Dental. What happened to them? They got letters from the Washington Dental Association telling them that it was illegal for them to do so, as it violated anti-trust laws.
So, in the end, what happened? Delta raised the costs to consumers, lowered the amount of money they paid out to Providers and profits went through the roof.
This is the system the insurance companies have bought themselves through politicians.
So what's the solution? Having the federal govt. knock the hard working doctors and dentists down instead (Obama voter preference)? Do nothing as deep rooted problems keep on keepin on (conservative voter preference)? I don't know how we solve these things with or without government. Although bitching about "rich" family practitioners making $165,000/year after a 12+ year college investment and a minimum of $1,000,000 investment seems the worst starting point to me.
In the end, I think the real problem is people wanting to live 90 years AND retiring at 62. The "problem" isn't about poor people not being able to afford health care (because penicillin is pretty damn cheap), it's about middle class wanting someone else to pay $3,000,000 of their h.c. costs while they sip margaritas in Florida.
Get rid of the early retirement for the rich on the backs of the hard working poor and suddenly this is a non-issue.