What's new
By:

Official UofU homer thread

prodigy said:
PI that was called, don't know what hatfield did wrong here
pi_on_hatfield.gif


also the same ref threw the late pi flag on porter which prolonged colorado's touchdown drive. unfortunately there isn't a good replay on that one
Click to expand...
You don't see what he did? He extended his arm on the player to keep him from making a move on the ball. A weak call, but proper one.

Sent from my A0001 using JazzFanz mobile app
 
bigb said:
Basing it off that criteria, PI should be called on every pass.
Click to expand...

gregbroncs said:
If they had made that same call all game Colorado sould have been flagged for PI on 25 plays.
Click to expand...

Well I didnt watch the game, but you arent allowed to do that as a defender. A lot of times in Football both the WR and CB will be jostle with each other for position and the refs dont call it if no one is going overboard, but in this one the only hands I see are from Utah. I think the ref would have held the flag but at the very end the Utah CB pushes off. You can see the Utah CB put his hand on the WR, then turn around and push off when he sees the ball coming to the inside.

The CB definitely had position on the WR. If the CB had tried to make a play on the ball instead of pushing off at the end, nothing would have been called. The WR did a good job of trying to make a play on the ball to sell the interference call. Was it a weak call, yeah, but the CB had no reason to use his hands, he already had great position, just make a play on the ball instead of holding.
 
Saint Cy of JFC said:
Well I didnt watch the game, but you arent allowed to do that as a defender. A lot of times in Football both the WR and CB will be jostle with each other for position and the refs dont call it if no one is going overboard, but in this one the only hands I see are from Utah. I think the ref would have held the flag but at the very end the Utah CB pushes off. You can see the Utah CB put his hand on the WR, then turn around and push off when he sees the ball coming to the inside.

The CB definitely had position on the WR. If the CB had tried to make a play on the ball instead of pushing off at the end, nothing would have been called. The WR did a good job of trying to make a play on the ball to sell the interference call. Was it a weak call, yeah, but the CB had no reason to use his hands, he already had great position, just make a play on the ball instead of holding.
Click to expand...
On at least 6 different occasions the defenders from Colorado were holding the receiver's arms preventing them from raising them to catch the ball. None of them were called. That PI you claim was PI, the contact was initiated by the WR because the ball was thrown short, the defender pushed him after the ball was already on the ground.
.
That said I didn't blame the officials for this game. Pac 12 officials being the worst possible officials is just a fact the Utes need to learn to deal with.
 
gregbroncs said:
On at least 6 different occasions the defenders from Colorado were holding the receiver's arms preventing them from raising them to catch the ball. None of them were called. That PI you claim was PI, the contact was initiated by the WR because the ball was thrown short, the defender pushed him after the ball was already on the ground.
.
That said I didn't blame the officials for this game. Pac 12 officials being the worst possible officials is just a fact the Utes need to learn to deal with.
Click to expand...

Yeah, the other images prodigy posted looked like PI too, so if it wasnt called both ways that sucks.

The ball may have been thrown short, but the CB didnt turn his head to make a play on the ball. Ive seen several instances where the WR tries to make a play on an underthrown ball but the CB doesnt turn his head and just blocks the WR and it's often called PI.
 
Just my $0.02 but PI and the way it is/isn't being enforced in both the NFL and NCAA is making football damn near unwatchable. For me, football has always been the 1 sport that I can constantly watch regardless of what teams are playing. 5 years ago, I would have called you crazy if you told me that my passion for watching football could ever start to dwindle, but it certainly is. It's to the point where you can't even watch a DB defend a pass without anticipating the flag coming out. To make matters worse, it seems like refs will key on a certain team during a game and they can't even breath on the receiver while the opposing team can get away with much more physical play (and yes, I feel this way when I'm watching teams I don't give a rats *** about). It's gotten to be a joke and it's ruining the game.

If I was an OC, I would just run "Go" routes every damn play and not even worry if the passes are completed. You're probably going to get a flag half the time.
 
Saint Cy of JFC said:
Yeah, the other images prodigy posted looked like PI too, so if it wasnt called both ways that sucks.

The ball may have been thrown short, but the CB didnt turn his head to make a play on the ball. Ive seen several instances where the WR tries to make a play on an underthrown ball but the CB doesnt turn his head and just blocks the WR and it's often called PI.
Click to expand...
He was looking toward the ball before the contact by the receiver.
 
gregbroncs said:
He was looking toward the ball before the contact by the receiver.
Click to expand...

Before the gif? Because the gif starts he is looking down field chasing WR, he turns his head and sees teh ball, but that is before he puts his hand on the WR. After that he continues to run forward while holding him, and not making a play on the ball.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top