What's new
By:

Power Rankings

Cappy_Smurf said:
Isiah Thomas does have some teamates who are good defensively. Not sure what that has to do with individual defensive ability though.

Anyway, I'm still waiting for any of the IT fans here to admit they'd trade any of our players for him. I've already stated there are at least 3 Jazz players I wouldn't trade straight up, and several others I probably wouldn't trade for him. The all star label is completely misleading in some cases, and this is a prime example IMO.
Click to expand...

Why would you ask a bunch of Jazz homers on a Jazz board who they would trade for Thomas? Fair price on this board would probably be Withey for Thomas + pick
 
How much is Isiah Thomas going to get paid once he becomes a free agent?

At his current price I would love to have him as a 6th man type player, never as a starter. But when he becomes a free agent in 2 years how much is anyone willing to pay a 5'9 player?
 
Cappy_Smurf said:
What was stupid was the comment that Boston was in a better position because they had an all star and Utah didn't.

So for all the posters with a dwarf fetish, how many Utah players would you take over Isiah Thomas? I'm taking 3 as of now with at least 1 Or 2 Borderline. Defense counts.
Click to expand...

5. Maybe 7.
 
NAOS said:
your famous google method produces results of 177 lbs. Most players play below their listed weights for a good portion of the season. You're taking a fat L on this one, douchenugget.
Click to expand...

Uhhh, Hayward is listed at 209 on Google. But everybody pretty much agrees he plays at 225 and weighs about 235 now.

Usually the weight they list is from the beginning of their careers. He's not huge, but Tony Parker definitely has average point guard size.
 
Would anyone trade Exum or Hill straight up for Thomas?

I don't think I would. Call me a homer, but I like the defense of our guys more than what Thomas brings over them offensively. Of course with Exum I'm also factoring in development.
 
fishonjazz said:
Idk.

Would the Celtics trade thomas for hill or exum?
Click to expand...

Probably for Exum depending on how his recovery grades out, but Hill presents age, contract, and redundancy issues with Smart. Smart has been traded twice in a short amount of time. I think he is a good band aid for a struggling team to get competitive but he isn't a long term answer for playoff success, kind of like Carlos Boozer frankly (although Boozer got further than Thomas ever will as a starter.) A fully realized Exum is a strong foundational piece to a contender. He isn't that yet, but he has a chance. Thomas will never be that because he cannot consistently overcome the gameplanning that will occur by really good teams over a seven game series. The deeper he goes, elite teams will punish him when he is on Defense and not allow him to "hide" behind Smart.
 
framer said:
Probably for Exum depending on how his recovery grades out, but Hill presents age, contract, and redundancy issues with Smart. Smart has been traded twice in a short amount of time. I think he is a good band aid for a struggling team to get competitive but he isn't a long term answer for playoff success, kind of like Carlos Boozer frankly (although Boozer got further than Thomas ever will as a starter.) A fully realized Exum is a strong foundational piece to a contender. He isn't that yet, but he has a chance. Thomas will never be that because he cannot consistently overcome the gameplanning that will occur by really good teams over a seven game series. The deeper he goes, elite teams will punish him when he is on Defense and not allow him to "hide" behind Smart.
Click to expand...

Who is this Smart that's been traded twice?
 
Stifle Tower said:
Would anyone trade Exum or Hill straight up for Thomas?

I don't think I would. Call me a homer, but I like the defense of our guys more than what Thomas brings over them offensively. Of course with Exum I'm also factoring in development.
Click to expand...

No.
 
b_line said:
Uhhh, Hayward is listed at 209 on Google. But everybody pretty much agrees he plays at 225 and weighs about 235 now.

Usually the weight they list is from the beginning of their careers. He's not huge, but Tony Parker definitely has average point guard size.
Click to expand...

Fine. The truth is that there's nothing reliable about the measurements Cy is using.

As for Parker, has he bulked up? Ever? He's 6', dome skulled, and well under 200 lbs. He's small. He's never been anything like an anchor on defense. And he's been awesome overall. Thomas just isn't as good, but that has less to do with the 3 inches difference between them than other factors.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top