So he's a tool because you don't like his suffix and he's overrated because you say so? This has nothing to do with your rabid allegiance to your team and/or fervor for the rivalry?
Sounds legit to me.
In a nutshell, I'd say you're pretty close. Normally I will base my feelings and opinions off of what I see -- I know, how weird is that? People who put their suffix's onto their names, willingly, are generally tools. While that is a pretty broad brush to use, I add it to what I've seen of him in interviews, on the field, etc. and he could be Spokesperson IV for Craftsman.
So what if it has to do with my rabid allegiance? BFD. I'm pretty sure I've seen a few Utah fans talking **** on Max Hall, even though he holds most of BYU's records -- does that stop you, or the rest of your kind from bad mouthing him? Hell, I actually saw some white trash butt-**** wearing a, "Max Hall Hates Me" shirt a few days ago. I was quick to mumble under my breath as he walked by that "It's cool, I do too." (no worries, I had my 4 year old with me; she would've kicked his *** if he tried anything)
Anyhow, to add to FavorFlave's brilliant rebuttal and back pedal, is there anyone that seriously thinks IV is going to be the best RB in the PUSS12?