Spida or Devin Booker?

[JazzMan4Life]

I saw this thread --- --- on reddit and couldn't believe that Booker was the runaway favorite.

Booker plays poorly against the Jazz and I don't watch the Suns outside of our games against each other so I'm obviously biased (along with all of us), but I think DM is far and away the better player.

Thoughts?

 

[infection]

This is where people really underestimate the psychological component of the game. It isn’t even close.

 

[Saint Cy of JFC]

To be fair to Booker, he has to play for the Suns.

 

[Jack Strop]

Not even close. I'm sure half the teams in the NBA would trade their top player for Mitchell.

 

[dong2ha]

a player that plays for the bad team.... well kyrie did that too for a while.


Sent from my iPhone using JazzFanz

 

[Douchebag K]

lol

 

[JazzMan4Life]

I'm just now realizing how stupid it was to make this thread a poll.

It's my first poll, please forgive me.

 

[NUMBERICA]

Not close.

 

[elan_prodigy]

I'm just now realizing how stupid it was to make this thread a poll.

It's my first poll, please forgive me.

Poll was naive. But I appreciate the forum link.

 

[SCS]

Spida. Not even close. And that's my unbiased opinion. I'm a fan of Booker and as a shooter he's amazing. But DM is a more complete player and as such he has a higher upside.

 

[JazzyFresh]

Booker easily...

Need that tank

 

[Nate505]

If there ends up being a single vote for Booker here they can GTFO.

 

[enchilada_style]

Booker's name has been out there a little longer so I understand why he'd get more votes on reddit.

 

[Jack Strop]

I'm just now realizing how stupid it was to make this thread a poll.

It's my first poll, please forgive me.

Poll was naive. But I appreciate the forum link.

But how often is a thread created where everyone on Jazzfanz agrees on something? We can all get along here...that's a victory!

 

[akirac73]

The Mitchell-Dwade comparison I get. The Booker-Harden comparison?...LOL

 

[Thee Idiotic Minivan K]

I'm just now realizing how stupid it was to make this thread a poll.

It's my first poll, please forgive me.

Haha. U beat me to it love it

Booker easily...

Need that tank

Just pretend we tanked and got the #1 pick last year

Booker's name has been out there a little longer so I understand why he'd get more votes on reddit.

Also factor in the fact DM plays in Utah, no one has seen DM play. Lol

The Mitchell-Dwade comparison I get. The Booker-Harden comparison?...LOL

I see it a little bit. Harden can play pg and sg equally well. That's where the comparison falters though as Booker looks like a pure sg trying to play pg. he looked bad last night at pg. the funny thing is DM comps to Harden a lot more then Booker, oh and Booker is not the better playmaker then DM. PERIOD!

 

[gregbroncs]

The Mitchell-Dwade comparison I get. The Booker-Harden comparison?...LOL

Yea, not even close. I also don't get them saying Booker looks to be the better playmaker? Booker is more like a JJ Reddick in his ideal role. A better player you would hope but more like Reddick than Harden.

 

[karl malone]

Booker's ceiling is a 2nd/3rd option on a championship caliber team ala Klay Thompson. Mitchell's ceiling is the best player on a championship caliber team ala Wade. Anyone who prefers Booker is either a Sun's fan or someone who's never seen Mitchell play. Or David Kahn.