I'd like to know how people define "athletic." As best I can tell, in basketball it implies someone can jump high, dunk, run fast, and, most likely, isn't white. By the standards I infer from its popular use, Tom Brady isn't at all athletic, yet he's arguably the NFL's GOAT. To play at high levels of sport, it's hard for me to believe that many people who lack true, advanced, and specialized athletic skills are going to make it.
I, for one, am tired of the cliched use of this term. (However, on my list of pet peeves, it actually rates pretty low, but since this is the topic of the thread . . ..)