Quite honestly, I understand this much better than you, and you are wise to discontinue.
No one has claimed otherwise.
I agree that women should compete against women, and men against men.
Transgender and sports
- Thread starter Beer
- Start date
I'm just relieved the topic of abortion was dropped.
gandalfe
Well-Known Member
Now that you mention it, I would like to point out that trans women are, with current medical science, pretty much guaranteed never to need an abortion.
It’s what you want to be the case. You want to sit here with semantics and act as though sports hasn’t been broken into women and men since sports began. There’s a spectrum on gender, none of it changes your actual sex. All you understand is the propaganda you want to push. And if that is what you want well….that’s what makes the discussion a complex one. The discussion on transgenderism itself is a complex one. I know I know…you know your political brand so to you it’s a decided discussion, but it’s not.
What you say when you wish to shut down discussion on a complex issue.
This should have nothing to do with politics at all. Gender identity isn't based on politics. It's not like a 13 year old says, I think I lean strongly liberal and identify as a Democrat, might as well become transgender... It fits my politics.
It's not that complex.
Just let them play and go back to not caring about women's sports.
Archie Moses
Well-Known Member
It's not about fairness equity.
It's about participating in athletic events with those who ate born biologically male or those biologically female. To me, that's how sports are divided and should be.
If you have a different opinion, I honestly respect you and that's your right. It's an agree to disagree.
Our high horses though, right?
It's about participating in athletic events with those who ate born biologically male or those biologically female. To me, that's how sports are divided and should be.
If you have a different opinion, I honestly respect you and that's your right. It's an agree to disagree.
Our high horses though, right?
Archie Moses
Well-Known Member
You're so edgy for supporting trans by being misogynistic.
Al-O-Meter
Well-Known Member
Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria (ROGD) affected by social contagion is not as far fetched as you seem to imply.
Discovering the Link Between Gender Identity and Peer Contagion
The lack of childhood history was critical, since traditional gender dysphoria typically begins in early childhood.
quillette.com
You’re right it shouldn’t, but it has been made into a political issue. And I agree, I think the discussion on kids sports like the legislature is having is stupid. I think the larger discussion on transgenderism and sports is a bit more complex. But certainly, leave the kids alone.
Archie Moses
Well-Known Member
Unfortunately, it has become political. Very much so too.
No, Archie, this isn't just about people being on high horses.
Life isnt fair though, and sports certainly arent fair. Some people are taller, more athletic, etc. Now there will be some chicks with higher T levels.
Archie Moses
Well-Known Member
When you, of all people, tell people to go eat a tran's persons dick, then what do you call that?
Your kid is trans so you can say that?
Bro, you threw me a curve there.
Last edited:
And how did it become political? What's the origin story on this?
The discussion on transgenderism in sports is complex. Again, you just don’t want to talk about it so you throw out nonsense. A lot of it is certainly politically motivated. That can be true and the discussion can also be worthwhile . But yes kids should be left alone and be allowed to play sports. Banning children from amateur sports is clearly abhorrent by the legislature.
It definitely in part is, just like most issues end up devolving into.
Whats complicated about kids playing sports? Just let them play. Little Sarah might get her *** kicked and be the 17th best swimmer in state instead of 16th. Boo hoo.
Okay, so let’s just remove mens and womens sports leagues and see how that works out. Just people of any sex, gender, etc. compete in the same league.