I don't think Chow could have been any worse this season. I'm glad he is leaving.
Hopefully Utah's offense puts up big numbers with a freshman QB next year. If that happens, recruiting should be just fine going forward.
I think Dave Schramm and Aaron Roderick did just fine calling the plays before Chow got here. If the Utes go with them again, fine by me. If a bigger name is hired, also fine by me.
Chow came in and used his established recruiting avenues to basically introduce Utah to the Pac 12. Well done. The Utah coaching staff no doubt has relationships with high school coaches that they never had relationships with in the past. But now that the relationships are in place, no need to keep Chow and his horrid play calling around.
Keeping Chow around would hurt the Utes long term. A stud QB would probably look at Utah and think, "Do I really want to go to the worst offense in the nation?" Chow had a big name back in the day, but how many high school juniors (and younger) are even old enough to remember Chow's glory days? And outside of some BYU fans, how many have parents who even care about Chow's glory days?
In addition to all of that, I think Utah would be on the hook for a pretty big salary this season if Chow stuck around.
All in all, I'm glad he came to Utah, but it was time for him to go. He did what he came to do (introduce Utah to the Pac 12 recruiting avenues) and was only hurting the team if he stayed any longer. Props to him and the University for handling this situation with class and dignity.