It is when the entire team fails to do anything with exception to Favors. .
Really? You might hate Al but the fact is that he did average 18 and 9 on 53% shooting in the playoffs. That is not "failing to do anything". Millsap was close to a bust on both ends of the floor. 12ppg on 37% shooting? Meh, we can get that from Kanter or Marvin or someone else in a couple of years. And this is not a one-off thing with Millsap. Earlier against the Lakers he was abused by Odom in the playoffs every year. For all the bashing Booz took, without him taking the offensive load Jazz do not have even the moderate success they did have.
And I never said Millsap needed to be a featured piece, but he's been forced to become that and has done a damn good job. I don't know why people so undervalue the ability of a player to play off and with other players, especially watching the Big Al debacle unfold in front of their faces.
For all your Big Al bashing(and I admite he does have flaws) he improved last season and was more consistent than Millsap who will have stretches during the season where he just disappears. Al was our offense night in and night out.You cant call a guy who averaged almost 20 and 10 last season as a debacle. Thats laughably biased. Especially considering that he had to make quite a few adjustments and play under a new coach without the benefit of a camp. Sure,he has some of the flaws which Booz did, but minus Boozer's attitude and nonchalant demeanor. He might not be needed 3 years from now, but he his helping the Jazz win games NOW. He is the only consistent low post scorer that we have now and the Jazz need that because they dont exactly have stud wings like Lebron or Wade or Harden.
Not everyone can be stars, but Millsap's been pretty close to that when no one else would or could step up. That's now two years running, and he'd be an even better piece if he could play off of someone and play in a real offense again
He's been playing off of someone his whole life. Earlier he played off of Deron and Booz and Okur and now he is playing off of Al, Hayward and others. In other words he has been enjoying the fact that he has never been the focal point of opposing team's defenses. And yet he disappears in stretches during the season and comes up short in the playoffs consistently.
Look, he is a nice role player to have and has a good attitude. He has been a feel good story for the Jazz. But lets not treat him like as if he is indispensable or that he has this magical basketball skills which would be demonstrated if only he had better players around him. Thats nonsense. He has limited skill sets(apart from his physical limitations) and for all his work ethic, he'll be a good 6th man to have AT BEST. If you are going to make him your second option then you are aiming to be a middling fringe playoff team and nothing more.
If it were only possible, I'd trade Millsap for Iguodola in a heartbeat.
A lineup of Al, Iguodola,Marvin,Favors,Mo and a bench of Hayward, Kanter,Tinsley, Evans,Burks would be pretty good.