What's new
By:

2022 Annual Jazzfanz All Time NBA Draft

The Fresh Prince said:
I was under the impression we are running a sim.
Click to expand...
This needs to be in one of the OPs, whatever it is that we're doing. Fundamentally changes how one should approach team building.

Which sim? Do they take season into account? It has to be compatible with the structure of the competition.
 
NUMBERICA said:
This needs to be in one of the OPs, whatever it is that we're doing. Fundamentally changes how one should approach team building.

Which sim? Do they take season into account? It has to be compatible with the structure of the competition.
Click to expand...
And how does the sim do player minutes? Bench and starters play the same minutes? Do we have to structure them?

Sent from my SM-A516U using JazzFanz mobile app
 
I'm happy to take specific directive from @Thee Idiotic Minivan K on how we're determining winners but I kinda need that to move forward.

If we're doing a sim or sims and voting, then we need to have a clear-cut set of rules to determine a winner. If you're running one sim and a vote, you can have the results disagree, then what? I had mentioned running two sims and whichever team wins two of three of voting/sim 1/sim 2, but then we gotta figure out which sims (maybe this has occurred).

Another idea is that any vote that one team gets a 2/3 majority of votes bypasses the sims.

I personally think voting works alright and is simple enough. Sims sound like they might provide some quantitative foundation that could be useful, but balancing the benefits of sims vs. votes is sticky.
 
Last edited:
The Fresh Prince said:
If there's one thing I disagree with in this draft is that round 1-6 is rewarded to the guys who got the first picks at the beginning. The guys who got the first picks in the draft get to have the BPA again in the 2nd half of the draft, which kind of makes them OP. I think it should've been the bottom picks get the first picks in the 2nd half of the draft.
Click to expand...
Whoever drafted first overall has the last pick in both the 2nd and 3rd rounds.
 
NUMBERICA said:
I'm happy to take specific directive from @Thee Idiotic Minivan K on how we're determining winners but I kinda need that to move forward.

If we're doing a sim or sims and voting, then we need to have a clear-cut set of rules to determine a winner. If you're running one sim and a vote, you can have the results disagree, then what? I had mentioned running two sims and whichever team wins two of three of voting/sim 1/sim 2, but then we gotta figure out which sims (maybe this has occurred).

Another idea is that any vote that one team gets a 2/3 majority of votes bypasses the sims.

I personally think voting works alright and is simple enough. Sims sound like they might provide some quantitative foundation that could be useful, but balancing the benefits of sims vs. votes is sticky.
Click to expand...

What do you idiots think about having the sim determine seeding for the vote? Someone else needs to run the sim though, thoughts?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Thee Idiotic Minivan K said:
What do you idiots think about having the sim determine seeding for the vote? Someone else needs to run the sim though, thoughts?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
I think that is certainly a great role for the sim. Are you suggesting that after seeding, then head-to-head competition is strictly voting, or voting + sim (maybe running a sim if one team doesn't have, say, a 60% majority of votes as a "tie-breaker"?)?

And then which sim(s) are we using?
 
I freaking hate technology I just updated a bunch of picks in op then forgot to save I hate all you idiots now you choose to get active.
 
NUMBERICA said:
I think that is certainly a great role for the sim. Are you suggesting that after seeding, then head-to-head competition is strictly voting, or voting + sim (maybe running a sim if one team doesn't have, say, a 60% majority of votes as a "tie-breaker"?)?

And then which sim(s) are we using?
Click to expand...
I like sims over a popularity vote

Sent from my SM-A516U using JazzFanz mobile app
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top