Alex Smith Watch 2010-2011

[C l u t c H 385]

Perfect example of what I said above Hall had 2x fumbles and an INT but one fumble his OL recovered and ran in for a TD and his D carried the team to a win by getting 3 INT's and scoring, the offense only put up 3 FG's if Alex got half that support the Niners win 3 games this year easy.

Yup, Hall blew mega chunks but the Saints offense ****ed over the Saints defense for my fantasy team.

 

[TroutBum]

A win is a win. I'll take it for a first time starter.

 

[//r00t 4 Jazz]

A win is a win. I'll take it for a first time starter.

No doubt I'm a Phins fan and I would take that win any day of the week but they won in-spite of the QB's performance not due to his performance.

 

[Deleted member 365]

When was Alex Smith drafted and how many millions of dollars have the 49ers wasted on him?

When was Max Hall drafted and how many thousands of dollars have the Cardinals invested in him?

And who has the better record right now?

Nuff said.

 

[calijazz]

Perfect example of what I said above Hall had 2x fumbles and an INT but one fumble his OL recovered and ran in for a TD and his D carried the team to a win by getting 3 INT's and scoring, the offense only put up 3 FG's if Alex got half that support the Niners win 3 games this year easy.

It's certainly not on all on Alex, but at some point the numbers don't lie. He makes WAY too many big mistakes. I've never seen so many tipped passes that have led to INT's than Smith (throughout his career, but this year especially). The accuracy just isn't there a lot of the time on short-to-intermediate throws. Unlucky on some of them? Sure. But that has pretty much been the case for Alex his entire career. At what point do you just cut your losses and move on? I think both parties could benefit from a fresh start. It's not meant to be in SF. I wish him well elsewhere (and yes, he will be elsewhere). I honestly think the Niners would at least be 2-3 or possibly 3-2 if they still had Hill at QB. While very unspectular himself, he doesn't press and doesn't try to make plays where their isn't one. He's smart with the football. That's Alex's main problem.

But you are right, the defense has also been a huge disappointment. It doesn't help that they are constantly defending a short field though...

Even the special teams was horrible last night.

 

[Duck Rodgers]

I invite all 9er fans to hop aboard the Raiders bandwagon.