Agree to disagree....but I like the lineup of
Harris
Hayward
Iggy
Milsap
Favors
compared to:
Nash
Hayward
Howard
Favors
Big Al
The way I see it, in lineup 1 we have no inefficient starter (maybe Harris is probably the worst, but he's actually pretty good IMO) whereas with lineup 2, you've got 2 of them playing 30+ minutes a game. Maybe Howard plays, 20 but that's not the point. You give 50 minutes to 2 players that are likely going to cost you maybe 4-10 points a game every game depending on their minutes. That's going to get you a lot more losses.
Not only that, but lineup 1 is a defensive beast. Besides Milsap, everyone else is at least an above average defender. I think lineup 1 is a top 10 defensive team.
Now if you get Rondo, that's a different story altogether. I just think that Rondo will go to the first team that overpays Boston if Boston IS looking to trade him.
I don't think Boston will take Big Al in a Rondo trade because they''ll be looking to rebuild and will want fresh legs. (I also didn't put Rondo in lineup 2 because I wouldn't know what you'd trade to get him. He's a superstar now and his value is probably insane. I think Boston would probably want Favors or Hayward in a Rondo trade)