At this point...

[Archie Moses]

Who would you rather have???

Alfonso Burke?

or

Homer... Deron Williams?


(In their rookie years?)

 

[Deleted member 848]

Originally Posted by Archie Moses
Dear Jazzfanz,

As I told my brother during the NCAA tourney, Burkes is a collegiate player. He'll "Eric Snow" it in the pros.

Signed,


Archie Moses.

 

[yamers]

Originally Posted by Archie Moses
Dear Jazzfanz,

As I told my brother during the NCAA tourney, Burkes is a collegiate player. He'll "Eric Snow" it in the pros.

Signed,


Archie Moses.

troll

 

[Archie Moses]

I'll admit, I thought Alfonso would have a career (missed banked layups) like Snow, but the dude is growing on me. Will he ever be as good as Williams in his prime? (years ago of course.)

 

[fallenchicken]

Prime Williams was better, certainly talent-wise. But right now? With Deron Williams crippling contract? Burke all the way..

 

[Hotdog]

Id take Burke in their rookie year's, but right now, I would still take Deron when he played for the Jazz. Burke is a stud, but he still hasn't reached Deron's level when he was in a Jazz uniform. Deron's performance in his 2nd year playoffs run was pretty damn good, especially against San Antonio.

 

[yamers]

Dwill is now an over-paid cry baby

Jerry's system made Dwill.

 

[Ferguson_Mellochill]

DWill was a more complete and dominant player than Burke has shown to be so far. Even in their rookie years, I'd probably still take DWill.

 

[spycam1]

 

[TroutBum]

I'd take a scorching case of anal crabs over DuhRon Williams, 10,000 times out of 10,000.

 

[Jazz4ever]

They are having comparable rookie years. DWill took huge steps in his 2nd and 3rd years though which might be a little unrealistic for Burke to match.

 

[Qman]

You take Deron 10 times out of 10. Deron had All-Star potential. Burke does not. Simply put Burke doesn't have the tools to get to the free throw line consistently. Now you might trade Deron in a few years but he always was a better talent.