I do agree with you.
However, what's the point of being constructive when it's been done over, and over, and over, and the individual has a history of not listening to the advice? Case in point, the "do I text her or not?"...overwhelming majority was to not do it. Does it anyways. I mean, why freaking bother try to help if he's not going to listen anyways?
So why respond at all, then?
How long did you keep your chest puffed out after basically telling him he's a douche?