Duncan > Malone?

[The Fresh Prince]

I love Karl and all , but Tim has shown his longetivity fa sho in the league. Still playing at a high level and has had much more wear and tear than Karl did at this stage of his career.

All in all though I'd say if Popovich coached Malone rather than Her that Malone would be rockin some gold.

 

[Beantown]

Can't compare, Malone played in a much tougher and talented generation.

 

[Saint Cy of JFC]

I love Karl and all , but Tim has shown his longetivity fa sho in the league. Still playing at a high level and has had much more wear and tear than Karl did at this stage of his career.

All in all though I'd say if Popovich coached Malone rather than Her that Malone would be rockin some gold.

Malone had played 2,000 more total minutes (regular season and playoffs) than Duncan at this point in Duncan's career. Malone had more wear and tear, if you count it by minutes played.

 

[The Fresh Prince]

Malone had played 2,000 more total minutes (regular season and playoffs) than Duncan at this point in Duncan's career. Malone had more wear and tear, if you count it by minutes played.

Bra.. Malone injury free until his final year .

 

[Saint Cy of JFC]

Bra.. Malone injury free until his final year .

That we know of. Maybe he just played through them? Point is, I would say Malone aged better than Duncan and held up through the wear and tear of high minutes better than Duncan. Spurs just got wayyyyyyyy better role players.

 

[8]

I might say Duncan > Malone, but would not use longevity in the argument at all. I'd give that edge to Karl tbh

 

[akirac73]

Karl Malone = GOAT PF

I'd be more inclined to say: Popovich > Sloan than Duncan > Malone

 

[8]

Interesting

I'd be more inclined to say: Duncan > Malone than Popovich > Sloan

Where's the poll?

 

[Saint Cy of JFC]

Duncan is totally a center now too.

 

[Fabtrey]

I love Karl and all , but Tim has shown his longetivity fa sho in the league. Still playing at a high level and has had much more wear and tear than Karl did at this stage of his career.

All in all though I'd say if Popovich coached Malone rather than Her that Malone would be rockin some gold.

longevity? Karl played till he was 40. karl played at a ridiculous level till he was 39.

but overall duncan was better because he had better defense and the intangibles. if you put a gun on me and have to choose 1 player to build a team around then i have to pick TD. brings the unique finnesse and length to the game, and he makes others better tad more than karl. and i love karl. karl is the 2nd best PF ever.

karl was clearly a better scorer doe.

 

[Deleted member 365]

Karl was awesome.

But Duncan is better.

Bigger, longer, and better.

 

[BENTLEY]

Duncan is totally a center now too.

This.