I think you are forgetting one thing about Gordon, he works his butt off while AK never did. I think it is a toss up and I would be happy with either player, however I think I would go with Gordon. When two players are basically the same level then I look at positional need.
His intangebles are highly rated, which gives me hope for his improve ment. Gordon was also all over the court with hustle and fight in him which is a great sign. I realize there are a lot of people who have overcome shooting troubles, but has anyone ever come from where AG is at this point?