Ya but this is going to be the #1 or #2 all time rated movie on IMDB. #1 or #2 can justify being a 9. No matter who you are.
No body sees The Godfather than goes... meh. Same with Shawshank Redemption
You're an absolute idiot if you think this is going to be even in the top 10 of IMDB. If you haven't noticed, Nolan's movies are severely overrated by the IMDB masses right out the gate and then they dwindle down. Remember The Dark Knight? Just thinking about this movie in the same breath of The Godfather and Shawshank Redemption shows how little you actually know about films. Hell, as good as Inception was, it can't even be mentioned in the same breath as The Matrix. Here's why:
Bland characters. Seriously, I can't remember a damn thing about those characters or any unique attributes they might have had besides those of Leonardo and Ellen Page, and even they were hardly that interesting.
Dialogue. Pretty much the whole movie's dialogue was spent explaining Nolan's complex concept. And this is related for why the first point was so bad.
Action scenes. You can balk at Archie all you want, but he's right: at no point did any of those generic soldiers seem to pose any threat to the team. They seemed like filler material to keep the "concept" rolling, throw a grenade here, ski down a mountain side while shooting there. The exception to this is the hallway spinning scene, that was very well done.
The first act. That was very sloppy. I understood everything that went on, but you look at the plot, it just seems like terrible writing. So they are in Saito's mind trying to steal his ideas, but then he knows they're in his mind, so he then flies over to them on helicopter and hires them to do Inception. Just a very ham-handed way of introducing the concept.
None of these completely detract from what was still a well directed, interesting movie. Like Archie, I'm not saying it's a bad movie, I would probably give it an 8/10 too. I'm just pointing out WHY it's not the next "The Godfather". I mean, for the love of God, I know you want to be excited that the next new thing is THE BEST OF ALL TIME, but please restrain your urge for hyperbole and see some reality.