I understand what you're saying, but isn't it somewhat paradoxical? Because you're defining what makes these players point guards based on their offense, but then defining Haywards position based on whether he can defend those people.
Where?
I understand what you're saying, but isn't it somewhat paradoxical? Because you're defining what makes these players point guards based on their offense, but then defining Haywards position based on whether he can defend those people.
Where?
It is not like you say and never was. I'll give you an definite example: the Lakers' backcourt with Magic Johnson and Byron Scott in the 1980s. On defense, the 6'4 Scott would most of the time guard the shorter backcourt opponent, usually a PG, and the 6'9 Magic would guard the tallest, usually a SG. Nevertheless no one ever suggested that Scott was the PG and Magic the SG on that backcourt. Positions are defined offensively, not defensively.
Where you said can he guard nba point guards consistently. How are you defining who these point guards are that he needs to be able to defend?
I'm looking at the other 29 NBA teams and who they start at PG....
Do I want Hayward guarding Lillard, Irving, Paul, Curry, etc.?
*And I said he can't* guard them consistently*
I think it's less about Hayward being able to guard those guys consistently and more about the smaller guys in the Jazz lineup needing a smaller dude to guard.
Hood might be quicker, but it's not like he has used quickness in his game so the difference between quickness of Hood to Hayward/JJ is probably negligible (and Hayward is probably quicker).
Yep. Hayward, hood, and JJ can all guard shooting guards.50% of the game tho.
Nah, the original point is who should be in the starting line-up at the wing. JJ and Hayward, or Hayward and hood.Well the original point is about Hood/Johnson/Hayward guarding Shooting Guards I believe
This is the original post that started this lame discussion lol.Well the original point is about Hood/Johnson/Hayward guarding Shooting Guards I believe
I think we are better off starting Hayward and hood rather than Hayward and JJ.Yeah, I'm really starting to wonder if he'll start, and then have Hood come off the bench.
Who you can guard is your NBA position.
Gordon Hayward can certainly run an offense, but can he defend NBA PG's consistently? No, so therefore he can't really be a PG.
Trey Lyles can shoot, dribble, and playmake but is he a wing player? No, because he can't guard wing players.