NAOS
Well-Known Member
I officially put Peyton as > then Brady. Despite only one super bowl win and that will likely stay at 1. Manning now has a 3-2 record in the playoffs where it matters against Brady.
Years the pats arent cheating they dont win.
I think in the Colts years Brady had the better team and when Manning won he overcame that with his own excellent play. In the Broncos years Manning had the better teams but Brady didnt have enough to overcome that.
I still begrudgingly put Brady in the top 5 greatest QB list though.
Stats for comparison:
Player G ATT COMP PCT ATT/G YDS AVG YDS/G TD INT LNG SCK RATE RSH YDS RSH ATT RSH TD SB Wins NFL MVPs
Peyton Manning[13] 266 9,380 6,125 65.3 35.2 71,940 7.7 272.1 539 251 86 299 96.5 669 429 18 1 5
Tom Brady[14] 225 7,792 4,953 63.6 34.6 58,028 7.45 257.7 428 150 99 382 96.4 843 489 16 4 2
Lets hear your Brady argument. Can we throw out the cheating years or no since those are his best?
you bitches with the cheating ****. So naive. And so wrong.