Cooked an insanely good Rib Eye recently. I've had Lugers, Del Friscos multiple times and I thought it was a tiny notch below there's.
Bought two legit cuts, each a little over a pound and probably around 1.5 inches thick. I put generous salt and pepper on each side and let them sit at room temp for about 45 minutes. I then patted them dry and put a little more salt and pepper on them. By this point, my gas grill (which had been on for about 10 minutes) was at about 300 degrees, my cast iron skillet having been on it the whole time.
I then went out and put a very generous chunk of butter on the hot skillet and let it melt and move around to coat the whole bottom and immediately put the two pieces of rib eye on and closed the top for about a minute and 30 seconds. Most of the high end steak places agree with getting their grill or broiler or whatever they use as hot as possible (800-1500 degrees) and I wasn't that hot by any means but it came out really well. After the 90 seconds, I turned them and let the other side do the same, getting a nice blackened char (but not toooooo much so) on each side. I then turned the burns down some and let them cook for another 5-7 minutes, flipping them a lot, putting a little more butter in with about two minutes left.
Very amateurish tbh. Very simple too. But good as ****. Like really similar to Del Friscos which to me is better than Lugers. My grill thermometer reads up to 900 degrees. I'm not sure how high it will actually go. But next time, I am gonna try to get that sucker to a good 550-600 and char each side for a minute before following a very similar routine. Good as ****. The butter makes the steak and a lot of the high-end places do that now. I'll post pics next time because they came out sexy as ****.
Ribeye is the easiest cut to cook. If u can not cook it you might as well cut off yer balls n fry them.
BTW who turns steak several times? Never heard of a man doing this.