I dont care if he is banned or not, I dont really read enough of his posts or really even know all of the message board rules. I am not sure how people get so many infractions, I have never got one.I think you read way too much into Dutch posts, GF.
He def leads right and likes to show it but he seems as if he was simply always looking to rile up those like GF with blanket statements which seem to me were always about 65% him/35% troll.
I would not ban him based on what I have seen. He does post things that are racist, homophobic and so on but that is not a reason to ban him. But Dutch is always trying to troll and push his luck with every things he posts, like you said. His goal on here is to push people buttons even at his own expense of looking dumb. I doubt he is not surprised he got banned he tries to push everything to the edge.
Ultimately he brings nothing productive to the board so its pretty meh if he is gone. He does not provide a good argument for much. He is barely a Jazz fan as well. Although we have a handful of non Jazz fans and even non NBA fans that are on here posting a lot like Babe, which I guess isnt a reason to ban someone either.