SaltyDawg
Well-Known Member
No one is committed until they sign. It's that simple. IMO, if you're "committed", you don't go visit other schools. I'm committed to my wife, so I don't go out with other women. I'm committed to my job, so I don't go out looking for a new one.
I agree with your overall point. If you are committed, you act like it. And that is why BYU pulled their offer to Schwenke, and why Utah pulled their offer to Moore.
However, a verbal commitment should absolutely be treated the same as a written commitment. If give a school a verbal commitment, and the school then starts offering your scholarship to someone else, that would be wrong. And it goes both ways too. If you tell the school you have accepted their offer, you should not be out selling yourself to other schools hoping for a better offer. Verbal commitments (should, and usually do) matter.
Again, I believe Moore was coming to Utah and was only trying to get a free vacation out of the Ole Miss trip. But I can certainly understand why Whitt pulled the offer when he learned about the Ole Miss trip.