What's new
By:

2019 Annual Jazzfanz AllTime NBA Draft - Round 1, Match 7 - Gandalfe vs Elan_Prodigy

Who would win in a 7 game series?

  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .
gandalfe said:
Probably not. The average NBA player is much better than ever today, and his coaches wouldn't have let him play that much. But he would have still been absolutely dominant.

Here's a great article (opinion, obviously) about his greatness: https://bleacherreport.com/articles...t-chamberlain-is-the-greatest-nba-player-ever
Click to expand...

No **** Sherlock. Thanks for agreeing with me ROTFL Everyone drafted in the first round were dominant. Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I don't like either lineup. Gandalfe starting 3 centers is terrible.

I like elan's team except AI at PG with this team but it's still okay. Moses is under rated and really good.
 
Barkley is not a 3. At all. But I voted for this dude because McHale, Barkley and Parker bring legit intangibles and winning to the table imo. The other team is a who’s who of headaches.
 
I went Elan. I’m a sucker for the real AI. my favorite none Jazz player of all time to watch. Kid played hard every play. Elan has too much talent to lose this match. Gandalfe just has a weird lineup IMO.
 
Gandalfe drafted one sf and he’s the backup sg?? He’s playing three centers, starting two pf’s and Has a sg playing sf on his bench. I think you over thought this. Lol
 
Ron Mexico said:
I don't like either lineup. Gandalfe starting 3 centers is terrible.

I like elan's team except AI at PG with this team but it's still okay. Moses is under rated and really good.
Click to expand...
You think Barkley is a Center? That's hilarious. He's an undersized PF, which is why I felt he could manage the SF, that and in his younger days he could definitely move like a guard. McHale is a PF, but I think he played a decent amount of minutes at C.

I agree, Moses is really good, especially if you count his time with the ABA. But Wilt is better.
 
NUMBERICA said:
I kind of hate everything surrounding Wilt Chamberlain. The gaudy, raw numbers he put up often gets wrapped into obvious tall tales about his prowess. If that production was not just hogging the ball and the tales of his prowess were so legit, he should’ve been as or more successful than Bill Russell, who ate his ****ing lunch. You know how many FG’s this superhuman had to put up to get 50 PPG? ****ing 40.

There is a reason these contests have recency bias, and it’s that we have better data on recent players and basketball is vastly superior now. That is the same reason we’ve never seen another Wilt Chamberlain as well.
Click to expand...
Bullcrap. Wilt would dominate today.
 
gandalfe said:
You think Barkley is a Center? That's hilarious. He's an undersized PF, which is why I felt he could manage the SF, that and in his younger days he could definitely move like a guard. McHale is a PF, but I think he played a decent amount of minutes at C.

I agree, Moses is really good, especially if you count his time with the ABA. But Wilt is better.
Click to expand...
Barkley played PF but I'm not sure he could play that today. I don't think he is fast enough. Honestly I think he would struggle with today's rules and style. But even if he could play PF he couldn't play SF for sure.

McHale played PF as well. But I don't think he is in today's game. But I guess it depends on the rules and style. I assume these players are playing today's rules.

Either way those 3 are a bad fit together as your SF, PF, and C in any rules. Then you add another poor for Harden. Who is a point guard at his best and ball dominate.
 
Elan's team got attitude and style. And I don't think gandalfe's team can keep up in a high tempo game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top