What's new

Backup 4/5 solution: Emmanuel Mudiay?

infection

Well-Known Member
Staff member
2018 Award Winner
2019 Award Winner
2022 Award Winner
Okay, so the thread title is a bit misleading. But most teams have gone small, and even if they haven't, many of us have been saying what a defensive liability the backup 5 is and will be now and especially come playoff time. We're starting to run Morgan out there, which is great and I hope it continues, and even Royce playing Rudy's role on defense. So that raises a few questions/observations. One is that Royce has been struggling more lately on quicker guards on the perimeter. In some backup lineups, does it make sense to move him up playing the 4/5 while we open up time for Mudiay? Moving Royce up even as a small-ball 5 really opens up our minutes to clear out the guard log-jam and allows us to replace more of Niang's minutes with Mudiay. Mudiay already is a better rebounder, grabbing more per minute and posting a higher rebounding %, which I would honesty expect to go up just by vacuum effect if he were out there as the 3/4 sometimes. His defense is better than Niang and he's a lot stronger. His ability to iso may be more valuable come playoff time.

Overall, I think this can improve defense and have more well-rounded play the more we integrate Mudiay/Morgan and minimize others. This doesn't work against LA. I'm still very much in favor of signing Udoh, but this is a good option using what we have. If we did sign Udoh, then FTW make Mudiay our backup 3/4 and have to take Niang out of rotation.
 
Okay, so the thread title is a bit misleading. But most teams have gone small, and even if they haven't, many of us have been saying what a defensive liability the backup 5 is and will be now and especially come playoff time. We're starting to run Morgan out there, which is great and I hope it continues, and even Royce playing Rudy's role on defense. So that raises a few questions/observations. One is that Royce has been struggling more lately on quicker guards on the perimeter. In some backup lineups, does it make sense to move him up playing the 4/5 while we open up time for Mudiay? Moving Royce up even as a small-ball 5 really opens up our minutes to clear out the guard log-jam and allows us to replace more of Niang's minutes with Mudiay. Mudiay already is a better rebounder, grabbing more per minute and posting a higher rebounding %, which I would honesty expect to go up just by vacuum effect if he were out there as the 3/4 sometimes. His defense is better than Niang and he's a lot stronger. His ability to iso may be more valuable come playoff time.

Overall, I think this can improve defense and have more well-rounded play the more we integrate Mudiay/Morgan and minimize others. This doesn't work against LA. I'm still very much in favor of signing Udoh, but this is a good option using what we have. If we did sign Udoh, then FTW make Mudiay our backup 3/4 and have to take Niang out of rotation.

um let's just grab someone from the buyout market....
 
If Mudiay was a better defender and shooter I could be down for this. Morgan is really the 5 in that alignment, not that it matters that much. I think Niang would provide more in the role than Mudiay because he's an elite shooter. The defensive upgrade I don't think is as meaningful. I would have liked to see us land a wing with a little more size like GR3 to use in that type of alignment.

I have felt Morgan is the answer at 5... still have questions at the 4... would like to see Brantley get a try, but would worry he would try to do too much. Not sure what the answer is at Niang's spot, might just be Niang until something is obvious. I think you can also whittle his minutes down with Royce, Bojan, Joe getting more time at the 4.
 
I wonder if Moe Harkless gets bought out... in theory I think he'd be good in the bench 4 role, but I'm pretty sure he's one of those guys you want on your team... then you get him and you are like "oh... that's why this guy always gets traded". Jeff Green is the king of these guys
 
I’m still waiting for someone to explain to me why Royce played only 19 minutes yesterday. I’d love a justification for that.
 
I’m still waiting for someone to explain to me why Royce played only 19 minutes yesterday. I’d love a justification for that.
Maybe he was jackpotting around in practice or something.

Not sure... I think we could use one more wing, but I think in the playoffs we can get Niang out of the rotation by ramping up other guys minutes a bit. Its not as big a problem as backup 5. Bradley should get zero minutes in these types of matchups.

If Morgan is good and is able to hold down the 5 it is a big deal for us. He could play alongside rudy if we needed to matchup with LA a bit... talking like 5 minutes a game maybe. He might have some positional versatility we desperately need.
 
Maybe he was jackpotting around in practice or something.

Not sure... I think we could use one more wing, but I think in the playoffs we can get Niang out of the rotation by ramping up other guys minutes a bit. Its not as big a problem as backup 5. Bradley should get zero minutes in these types of matchups.

If Morgan is good and is able to hold down the 5 it is a big deal for us. He could play alongside rudy if we needed to matchup with LA a bit... talking like 5 minutes a game maybe. He might have some positional versatility we desperately need.
I know you say that Bradley shouldn't get any minutes in these matchups, and I agree, but it raises a bit of the assumption that perhaps he's somehow more playable against someone like LAL. I mean, maybe if he's covering Dwight, but what if it's AD out there are the big man? I'm afraid we'll go to that as the default just because of size.

We really need Ekpe.
 
Watching March 1 (the deadline for signees to be playoff eligible) come and go is like watching someone get hit by those stupid skeleton turtles in a Super Mario castle, becoming small, having the mushroom drop from the sky, and instead they rush to the door to fight the koopa, rather than collecting the mushroom first.
 
Back
Top