MoreFeasts
Member
Calm down. You know it's just a TV show, right?
Jesse got Jane using after she was trying to get clean. Jesse killed Jane.
Jesse got Jane using after she was trying to get clean. Jesse killed Jane.
Breaking Bad (thread will have *spoilers*)
- Thread starter sirkickyass
- Start date
MoreFeasts
Member
YB and fishon say that Jesse blames himself for Jane's death.
And the plane crash, nursing home explosion, school shooting, etc.
spycam1
Well-Known Member
Jessie blamed/blames himself. But yes, Walt essentially killed her. He even cried about it.
dogtoucher
Member
Good. Good. You are a good man
DutchJazzer
Banned
essentially?
well imho walt murdered her outright
MoreFeasts
Member
Jane and Jesse were each more responsible for Jane's demise than Walt was.
Walt wasn't the one who got Jesse and Jane using heroin, Jesse and Jane did that to themselves.
If Jane didn't want to choke on her own vomit, she shouldn't have done drugs.
You and Jesse think Walt controls everything, but he doesn't. Stuff happens.
You could explain yourself using words.
Are you saying that Walt rolled her on her back and caused her to choke?
Walt wasn't the one who got Jesse and Jane using heroin, Jesse and Jane did that to themselves.
If Jane didn't want to choke on her own vomit, she shouldn't have done drugs.
You and Jesse think Walt controls everything, but he doesn't. Stuff happens.
You could explain yourself using words.
Are you saying that Walt rolled her on her back and caused her to choke?
jjscap
Well-Known Member
It's Walt's fault or at least that's what we're supposed to conclude. In the original script, Walt actually kills her by strangling or something.
Gilligan told that was the only time AMC intervened telling "No, that's too much!". So they changed it.
MoreFeasts
Member
So Walt did not touch her then.
Walt did not make her take heroin.
Jesse was the one that got Jane back on drugs.
Jane was the one that got Jesse taking heroin.
Did Walt know how long was she choking before he got there?
Walt did not make her take heroin.
Jesse was the one that got Jane back on drugs.
Jane was the one that got Jesse taking heroin.
Did Walt know how long was she choking before he got there?
Of course
MoreFeasts
Member
1) Hearsay about hearsay. Lots of room for misinterpretation in the line of retelling.
2) Thousands of plot points were considered but did not happen.
3) Just because Walt did or didn't do something, does not mean that everyone else is powerless and innocent, and that everything is controlled by Walt.
4) We differ on our interpretation of Gilligan's words.
5) Gilligan isn't a God either. His script can be open to other interpretations of truth besides his interpretation.