If I pay $1,000,000 for a piece of real estate and run a bakery out of the bottom that brings in $100,000 per year, I cannot write off $100,000 of the $1,000,000 investment the first year. I would have lost money on paper but have to pay taxes because I didn't lose any money in reality as the asset is still likely worth $1,000,000.
Conversely, if I buy a bunch of computers to fill a leased building for a call center, I can depreciate the electronics on a 5 year schedule because their value is expected to be reducted proportionally. I can also write off the entire leasing expense as it I didn't realize an asset from this cost.
Appreciation can go into the income statement and get taxed. There are different methods of accounting that companies can adopt and some investments will get taxed while others won't. Mining accounting is different from what I gather as there are specific issues that we need to tailor the tax code to. We make special laws for every industry and have all that GAAP and FASB crap...
Conversely, if I buy a bunch of computers to fill a leased building for a call center, I can depreciate the electronics on a 5 year schedule because their value is expected to be reducted proportionally. I can also write off the entire leasing expense as it I didn't realize an asset from this cost.
Are you saying that in any other industry, he gets taxed for making a $3.9M profit, instead of writing off a $100K loss, but since this is oil, that doesn't happen? It would seem to me the real problem is that other industries do get taxed that way. If as an individual, I patent a product, and that patent has an estimated value of $30K, I don't start paying taxes until I start selling rights or I sell the patent outright, to my understanding.
Appreciation can go into the income statement and get taxed. There are different methods of accounting that companies can adopt and some investments will get taxed while others won't. Mining accounting is different from what I gather as there are specific issues that we need to tailor the tax code to. We make special laws for every industry and have all that GAAP and FASB crap...