The value of top picks is far too great to allow the outcome to be left entirely to chance. Enough picks can remain random, such that the league can maintain its position that "Picks are random." However, the number of fortuitous outcomes for the league are too numerous and consistent for the odds to say this is random. A few examples:
- The LA Lakers are the NBA's most important franchise for TV ratings, literally holding down the west coast time slots. The Lakers moved up in the lottery 4 times consecutively, receiving picks #2, #2, #2, #4. Mathematically, this is not impossible, but it is improbable.
- Amidst this string of good luck for the Lakers, Lebron moves from Miami to LA in free agency, but the team around him isn't good enough to compete in the playoffs. Lebron misses something like 1/4 of the season with some nagging injury (a sore groin, lol). Anthony Davis concurrently tries to force a trade to the Lakers, literally quitting on his New Orleans Pelicans team and leaving them in shambles. Both the Lakers and the Pelicans franchises are in a state of disarray. Then low-and-behold, the Lakers move up from #10 in the lottery standings into the top 4, so they can add the #4 pick to their young players, Ingram and Ball, in a trade package to the Pelicans to acquire Anthony Davis. As 'fate' would have it, the lottery gods also give the Pels the #1 pick in the draft to start their rebuild with Zion Williamson. The league gets a win-win. The Lakers are now a contender, TV networks have something to talk about, and the Pels have high-level lottery talent to stabilize their franchise and rebuild. Whew! Crisis averted.
- Houston Rockets ownership took huge financial losses during the Covid pandemic. (They're largely invested in commercial real estate.) The Rockets, who just lost James Harden when he basically checked out on them Anthony Davis-style, get four consecutive top-4 picks (Jalen Green, Jabari Smith, Amen Thompson and Reed Sheppard). Now Houston tanked their season for each of these picks. The odds were decent for them to get a high pick in each draft individually, but to move up 4x in a row is still a fairly low probability--like .50 * .50 * .50 * .50 = 6.75%. It's like flipping a coin 4 times and getting heads each time.
- Michael Jordan sells the Charlotte Hornets. The new ownership gets the #2 pick in the draft (Brandon Miller), which effectively helps to sweeten the deal. The deal officially closes 7 weeks later.
- The Milwaukee Bucks are sold to new ownership, who likewise then get the #2 pick in the draft (Jabari Parker), which effectively helps to sweeten the deal.
- Cleveland fans were literally rioting and burning Lebron jerseys when he left in free agency to go to Miami. The following summer, the Cavs get the #1 pick to draft Kyrie Irving and start their rebuild. One #1 pick isn't enough for the franchise to recover from losing Lebron, so then Cleveland proceeds to soon win two more #1 picks back-to-back (Anthony Bennett and Andrew Wiggins). Fans get over losing Lebron somewhat, though he decides to go back to Cleveland to team up with Kyrie if the Cavs will trade one of those #1 picks back to Minnesota for Kevin Love. Such a feel-good story.
If I'm a conspiracy theorist this year, I don't see a particularly egregious situation that requires intervention, but I'd keep an eye on Brooklyn. The way things rapidly fell apart with James Harden, then Kyrie Irving, then Kevin Durant all leaving might be enough of a black eye for the league to want them to move up this year. The Sixers' situation is another to watch. I don't know what the protections are on the pick owed to OKC, but I'd be surprised if the league is going to allow the Thunder to get another lottery pick to add to what appears to be the best team in the league. Why? Because then the small-market OKC Thunder will be in the Finals for the foreseeable future. See what the TV ratings look like when the Thunder and Cavs meet in the Finals this year. If I'm the league, I'm a bit tempted to put Cooper in a big east-coast market like Brooklyn or Philadelphia.
At some point, it wouldn't surprise me if the league simply asks Cooper Flagg's camp if there are teams in the lottery he'd be willing to play for. After all, a big-name, high-impact white American player is going to draw attention and help carry the league's image with Lebron aging out. Gilbert Arenas, in one of his podcasts, made it sound as though the league basically set up Wembanyama with the Spurs so that he'd be put in a good situation to develop and be successful.
That said, if I'm the league I'd be okay with franchises like Charlotte, Washington, Toronto and Utah getting guys like Ace Bailey and Kasparas Jakucionis.