What's new
By:

Is Tom Brady the best football player of all time?

Is Tom Brady the best football player?

  • Yes

    Votes: 6 27.3%

  • No (reply who is)

    Votes: 16 72.7%
  • Total voters
    22
Saint Cy of JFC said:
It's cute how you pick and choose when you just want to look at a raw stat like TD's and when you don't. Let's not take any context of style of play or teammates in when we rank players!
Click to expand...

I never said to remove stats. If you remove stats like passer rating, winning %, playoff wins and Superbowl wins then maybe Bree's has been better than Brady.

But I will go ahead and look at those stats.
 
Beantown said:
I never said to remove stats. If you remove stats like passer rating, winning %, playoff wins and Superbowl wins then maybe Bree's has been better than Brady.

But I will go ahead and look at those stats.
Click to expand...

I dont actually think Brees > Brady, but if you apply your same logic to them as you do Bennett, you would probably have to say Brees is better. Just using Beantown logic.
 
What happens when you take away that 3 TD game against the Browns? In football, there's a tendency for some statistical categories to get strangely inflated by odd games. It's fair to say that his TD numbers are more of an outlier than a revelation of the player. He definitely was not one of the best TEs this year.

And Beanclown was stoked because of the two TE sets.... and well, that never really materialized in an impactful way.

Beanclown with the L, per usual.
 
Saint Cy of JFC said:
I dont actually think Brees > Brady, but if you apply your same logic to them as you do Bennett, you would probably have to say Brees is better. Just using Beantown logic.
Click to expand...

Wrong again.

My opinion was that I believed Bennett was going to have an elite year. Statistically Bennett has had an elite year.

The stats prove my point.
 
Beantown said:
Wrong again.

My opinion was that I believed Bennett was going to have an elite year. Statistically Bennett has had an elite year.

The stats prove my point.
Click to expand...

They don't..... they prove he had a decent year and got some TD's because of an elite offense.
 
NAOS said:
What happens when you take away that 3 TD game against the Browns? In football, there's a tendency for some statistical categories to get strangely inflated by odd games. It's fair to say that his TD numbers are more of an outlier than a revelation of the player. He definitely was not one of the best TEs this year.

And Beanclown was stoked because of the two TE sets.... and well, that never really materialized in an impactful way.

Beanclown with the L, per usual.
Click to expand...

When you have to justify stats it never helps your argument.

Stats > Opinions
 
Beantown said:
Tied for 2nd in touchdowns among his peers is elite.

Again, you are justifying stats. You would be a horrible lawyer.

stats > opinions
Click to expand...

What if Olsen played in that offense?
What if Kelse was in that offense?
What if Graham was in that offense?
What if Rudolph was in that offense?

Bennett put up OK stats in an offense that is extremely TE friendly with, by your own assertion, the greatest QB of all time.

He is an OK TE.
 
Saint Cy of JFC said:
What if Olsen played in that offense?
What if Kelse was in that offense?
What if Graham was in that offense?
What if Rudolph was in that offense?

Bennett put up OK stats in an offense that is extremely TE friendly with, by your own assertion, the greatest QB of all time.

He is an OK TE.
Click to expand...


If I was an idiot like you.....I could try to justify stats and say this.........


Because Bennett was in an elite offense he was actually at a disadvantage....he was targeted about 40% LESS than those players you mentioned.


But no need to justify. The stats speak for themselves.

stats > opinions
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top