Jamal Murray regular season and playoff FTr is about 20% which screams "role player" more than "star player". Key on the other hand was 27.5% on his rookie season and 43.6% this year, which is SGA level FTr.
Lavine on the other hand is a basketball moron (a talented one, but still a moron) who despite his god given gift to score and shoot hasnt figured out how to provide any other value to his team. He is also one of the most stagnant off ball players you will ever see in the NBA. DId you happen to know that Keyonte already has two more 10+ assist games than Zach does in his career?
I get it that you werent making comps, but Keyonte is gonna end up being way better offensively than those two. Way better. But defense I'm not gonna argue at all since he just doesnt play like he cares 100% of the time. Murray also coasts a lot, so I guess its not always a death sentence to a guard, but I do hope he doesnt end up being that guy.
I'm rather surprised if what you say about him and Nurk is true. since it feels like Key plays PnR pretty well these days. I guess I take an L on that one.
I mean….I’m all about FTR but my process is more involved than that. Same goes for assists. I take a more holistic view of these players. Of course Key is better (or worse) than these guys in certain areas. But I’m not cherry-picking one thing or the other when speaking to a player’s overall value. My comparison to Murray, or more accurately Murray’s level, is a more comprehensive process than looking at FTr.
And this kinda just goes back to the spreadsheet criticism. We’re both leaning on stats, just different ones. I don’t think pointing out random stats is a better process than taking everything to account, especially impact numbers. RAPM is spreadsheet, but FTr is also spreadsheet.
Murray represents a borderline elite offense player with bad, but not horrible defense. If you’re putting extra weight on what he’s doing this year, you could argue he’s even higher than that. Lavine represents someone who is very good on offense, but maybe not as elite has the raw numbers suggest and someone who is actually one of the worst on defense. Those are the offensive and defensive ranges I can see Key landing at.
Last edited:

