OK, so I don't really have inside knowledge. I'm the guy who sat on the sandstone bluffs overlooking town, and thought things through while watching the other high school kids crusing the Boulevard. I don't believe in "stupid", and I look for actual reasons why things are what they are.
If the Palestinians and Israelis were just two cultural groups in the same small niche, I'd expect after a while there'd be markets where they traded stuff. There'd be interest in getting along and getting ahead. When that doesn't happen, even across the religious divide, we need reasons.
There a reason the Israelis have kibbutz "collectives". Lots of believers in Marxism. Lots of socialists. The tribesmen of Israel were strictly non-collective people oriented towards private property under the tribal territorial and priestly ministrations. No mention of a communal farm, but ideas about landowners at least leaving the gleanings for the poor.
There is a reason why the Palestinians are socialist, as well. It's western infiltration, communist cell organizations that act to coordinate schools and communities. Lots of Obamas moving in their streets.
If left to themselves, these two peoples would make peace and merge. Really.
The reason there is war is because outsiders manipulate things within the two cultures. Might be because the Israelis are advanced New Worlders and the Palestinians are propagandized shopkeepers.... but really it's the ideas being foisted on the people....by outsiders.
OL, I didn't even know this. I mean the maps. Especially the latest 2011. I was there in 1989. We could go anywhere, the whole country. I stayed one night in a place in the Palestinian side. They had their own police, and there were checkpoints where you crossed(sometimes, not always) The Israelis had military people with their military rifles sitting in booths in strategic places, the Palestinians had the equivalent in their strategic places.
Even then, I was aware that millions of Russians had immigrated, practically doubling the population in twenty years. Yah, they were Jewish, some say.... those some dispute it. Ashkenazis supposedly from a tribe of Siberian wanderers who wanted an identity that would allow them to settle and start farms....which was possible under the Czars, for Jews.
The 2011 map reflects the fact of settlements, maybe communes, where these immigrants have taken root. I don't know anything about property issues there, as to individual ownership of land. Seems to me, that, by now.... after 5000 years of people doing settlements, the land might all be owned by somebody. Wonder if there has been a sell-off by Palestinian owners...
I don't think the UN did anything but recognize the facts already existing on the ground. Maybe the Palestinians will be absorbed. It would be interesting if, in that event, individual Palestinians decided to live peaceably and go about their lives..... It's not like they wouldn't have any human rights at all.....maybe they should build their own communes.
The Israelis, btw, have built the largest desal plant in the world, which produces the cheapest desal water in the world. And they are about 100% on the latest conservation methods. On those terms, the population can double yet again.....
Wow, I'm surprised you haven't seen those maps. I don't think you're right in that the UN did anything but recognize the facts existing on the ground. If you look at the first map where jews have slowly bought Palestinian lands that was bit by bit, piece by piece, very small amount. Then after the UN Partition plan, literally overnight, half of the land was literally allocated to jews. Imagine that. You own a piece of land, then one day somebody comes along and said we'll half it and someone else will live in the other half. All this was done, as I understand, partly to alleviate jews' suffering after the World War II, and if you are opposed to it you're labelled anti-semite.
Again I don't have a horse in this race, but how is that fair?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Plan_for_Palestine
This was jews settlement in 1944:
And this is the UN Partition Plan 1947:
In the forties both of these groups were viewed as lesser people. Many still feel that way today. I think that many in the UN hoped that Israel would be the final solution to the Jewish question. The allies may not have believed in gas chambers but they weren't exactly the champion of the Jews either. Giving them somewhere to go willingly other than "here" was a tidy solution. None of them gave a **** that Arab Muslims happened to be there. Not in the slightest. The way they saw it this was British territory. The English were making a sacrifice not the Arabs.