Example I've used is we each have a little girl, that had a nightmare and is crying in her bed in the middle of the night. Neither of us would just forsake her and let her cry. Both of us would go to her, both would comfort, both would likely be effective in making her feel better.. the only slight difference is I may have prayed for her.. and gave the glory to God for her feeling and sleeping better.. whereas the atheist doesn't pray and gives the glory to self.. in the end, the result could be identical, which makes our lives very similar....
Personally, I don't feel much "glory" for simply having a little empathy. At best, it makes me "not psychotic".