billyshelby
Well-Known Member
BS, you never responded to my question about why you think Matthews is not athletic. Seems to me the guy has speed to burn, good quickness, decent hops, and is strong as a bull. Sure, a lot of NBA players could fit that description, but when we're talking non-athletic that isn't a description that fits Matthews. I think of someone like Memo, a big lumbering guy with great skills but little hops or foot speed.
Why do I need to? Matthews is short, with poor length, and he can't jump. His shot is a modified set shot, not a jumpshot, mostly for that reason. As a consequence, he needs it to be set up for him. He can't just rise up against a defender to shoot. Defensively, those limitations show up against bigger wings no matter how fundamentally sound he is. I don't think he has anything other than average quickness, he just plays hard and has good instincts for the break. He OVERCOMES his athletic limitations through headiness, through intensity. He's tough. He's a crafty player. I love those qualities about him. But how many times last year did you look at the guy Wes was defending and say to yourself, 'Wes is a better athlete than that guy"? Not many if you were being honest. We can disagree that his athleticism is less important relative to how much he can improve, but I find it hard to believe you don't realize that Wes doesn't stack up well athletically with other 2 guards in the league. In fact, that's the single greatest reason he didn't get drafted.