History was my subject, and I spent many years in it's study. It's a vast subject of course. I wanted to know what a study of history could tell me about human nature. I was lucky, very lucky, to learn a few valuable lessons. One in particular seemed particularly valuable, a general observation that seemed well worth remembering, the kind of thing that, if remembered by many, could prevent the mistakes history is so known for, the reason we say understand history or be doomed to repeat it. And that simple lesson was: Evil is banal, and can pass unrecognized it it's own time. Of course, I'm hardly the first or only student of History to recognize the truth in that observation. I thought of that lesson the first week Trump declared, but did not want to dwell on it. Surely, everything he said, the personality he displayed, was a cynical ruse designed to simply win those primaries?
Maybe. Or maybe it's our turn to hand the reigns of power over to an unstable nut. Maybe it's our turn to forget the lessons of history.
Until yesterday, I had never heard of Richard North Peterson. But I thank him for being one of the few so far to zero right in, and spell out, eloquently, and in no uncertain terms, what is before us. Tell it like it is, Mr. Peterson:
"So how have we fallen prey to a man who, by the damning evidence of his own behavior, is psychologically unfit to be president? When did boasting top coherence; mindless posturing become strength; a talent for ridicule supplant experience or judgement; a gift for scapegoating surpass wisdom or generosity? Why must we even contemplate someone with this stunted inner landscape as the world’s most powerful man?
Much of the answer lies in a failure of our institutions - governmental, economic, political and social - to maintain our trust. This has bred a popular flailing born of frustration and despair: the desire to tear down those structures which, all too many feel, have betrayed us. We can see it in the refusal of Trump’s followers to accept any criticism of their leader; see it, too, in the cadre of Sanders supporters who insist that electing Trump will unleash the chaos from which revolution springs. For all too many, anger has drowned reason.
But two institutions deserve special condemnation.
First, the Republican Party. For too long it fed the GOP’s middle and working class base easy scapegoats - Washington, minorities - while the Paul Ryans of the party contravened its voters’ interests: pushing free trade, reduced entitlements, and tax cuts for the rich. Trump is what happened to the party when its electorate spat this pablum out.
Even more contemptible is the party’s embrace of Trump. For we have reached, as David Brooks wrote, the GOP’s “McCarthy moment” - a turning point when concern for country should override grubby pragmatism. Except this reckoning is even more pressing - Joe McCarthy was not running for president; Donald Trump is. We cannot - must not - invest him with this power.
Beyond peradventure, Trump’s incapacities transcend issues or ideology, or the most vehement objections to the policies or persona of Hillary Clinton. It is one thing to preserve the party by fighting for its congressional candidates. But by pretending that Trump is fit to be president, the Republican Party has become the political and moral equivalent of a criminally callous auto manufacturer, willing to sell cars with defective airbags and exploding gas tanks.
Worse. For they are not selling us combustible cars; they are selling out the country. It is hard to put a name to their dishonor.
But, with honorable exceptions, the broadcast media has been even more shameful and complicit. Worst of all is cable news -in pursuit of revenue and ratings, they have given Trump $3 billion in free advertising, feeding his candidacy - and his ego - by spreading the mythology of his imperviousness and power.
Wallowing in self interest, they have shrunk from saying what must be said: that Trump is unfit for higher office. Instead, they have breathlessly parsed his every move as if he were something grander, yet more normal, than a mentally disordered demagogue bereft of principles and starved for adulation.
Only lately have a few talking heads begun to notice, with perplexity and wonder, that Trump’s behavior is, well, kind of strange. Really? They have countenanced lie upon lie; recast his disturbed behavior as strategic genius; marveled at the immunity from his own vacuity and vulgarity that they have helped create. Even more than Trump himself, they have thrust “Trump” upon a confused and vulnerable country. By doing so, have disgraced themselves and betrayed their obligations to the rest of us.
One thinks of Edward R Murrow’s admonition when so many of his peers in television cowered before Joseph McCarthy :” This instrument can teach, it can illuminate, and even inspire, but only if humans go to the extent to use it. Otherwise it is merely wires and a box.” Or, now, something worse - a tool of disinformation and intellectual and moral degradation, turned over to a dangerously unbalanced man for whom this is the essence of his nature.
The Republican Party is beyond redemption. The media have five months left. Let them use it well."
---------------------
One of the hardest things a person can do is extract oneself from one's own time and place, the better to see what usually only the passage of time can reveal, what usually only History can reveal. None of us can do such a thing perfectly; we are the products of a particular time and place in History. But to the extent one can, the ability to see clearly what is really going on does improve. I highly recommend such an exercise.....