As for Franklin's comment, only a minority of Jews, in general, actually practice the religion, or possess any deep faith. Most are culturally Jewish. That is even more obvious when it comes to the intellectual Jewish clique. But then again, what percentage of biologists or physicists are believers? 5%? Some people manage to have religious faith, while maintaining their scientific objectivity. But it's somewhat difficult.
*franklin
Siro, wiping aside the history that one way or another led to Jews being so damn smart can't be that simple.
I'm well aware of the atheist, ethnic Jews who have risen to the top in every field imaginable. That doesn't score a point in the face thousands of years of history that got us to where we are today. The religion obviously did not breed a bunch of dumb asses.
I think a better way of looking at it through the atheist lens would be an evolutionary argument where only the smartest survived their history of persecution. IMO, that view pretty much equalizes the atheism vs. religion debate as far as intelligence is concerned.