What's new
By:
Filters

The Perfect Movie

colton

colton

All Around Nice Guy
Contributor
I caught the ending of The Princess Bride with my 16 year old daughter a day or two ago. We've of course seen it before, but were drawn in on a TV showing just before they stormed the castle. When it got over, my daughter said something like, "Why don't they make perfect movies any more?" I asked her what she meant, and she explained that most of her very favorite movies--ones that were done just perfectly in her estimation--tended to be from the 80s or 90s. That, combined with the recent Harold Ramis thread got me wondering--what are the perfect movies, movies which in my opinion accomplished their mission to the utmost extent and are a pleasure to watch over and over? Ones like the Princess Bride that I would probably not be able to turn away from were I to catch them playing on TV half way through. As a counter-example, I recently watched Frozen and while it was a great movie it clearly had a couple of problems in the storyline. The answer to this question will vary person by person, but I started making my own list.

(in alphabetical order)
Amadeus
Arsenic and Old Lace
Back to the Future
A Christmas Story
Groundhog Day
Mary Poppins
Men in Black
Monty Python and the Holy Grail
The Princess Bride
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Shrek
Star Wars (episode 4)
Strictly Ballroom

I could probably figure out a few others to include, but that's a good start. Anyone want to dispute my choices, or add to the list? (My own tastes clearly run to the PG variety.)
 
Good list. I agree with most of them you listed Colton.

Groundhog Day is IMO the most perfect movie, and one of the most brilliant movies ever made. They paid such attention to detail and carried it through what is actually a much more complex storyline than you would think on just one viewing with very few mistakes in continuity, and the acting, aside from the manikin named Andie McDowell, was superb. "Ned? Ned Bryerson?" *PUNCH*

Another for me was The Matrix. Not either of the sequels but the first was a classic work of art, not just a sci-fi movie, with groundbreaking filming techniques that greatly added to the story being told instead of being distracting as cutting edge filming tends to be, which has been copied in nearly every action movie since. Plus the use of real actors in most of the sequences and minor use of full-on CGI is impressive (this is one reason the sequels fell flat with fake-neo fighting a million fake-smiths....meh).

If we are talking about watchability, Mr. Deeds (the Sandler version) is right up there too.
 
This would be my whole list personally:

Home Alone 1 and 2
Goonies
Good Will Hunting
21
The Bourne Movies
Dumb and Dumber

And those also happen to be the only movies I own. Never have wanted to double watch anything else.
 
LogGrad98 said:
Another for me was The Matrix. Not either of the sequels but the first was a classic work of art, not just a sci-fi movie, with groundbreaking filming techniques that greatly added to the story being told instead of being distracting as cutting edge filming tends to be, which has been copied in nearly every action movie since.
Click to expand...

Good addition. I just watched it with my kids a month ago (edited version), and it is a great movie, perhaps "perfect".

Plus the use of real actors in most of the sequences and minor use of full-on CGI is impressive (this is one reason the sequels fell flat with fake-neo fighting a million fake-smiths....meh).
Click to expand...

That was one of my replies to my daughter about why so few modern movies make it on to the Perfect list--the use of CGI for the most part just makes otherwise great action scenes feel fake. And it's easy for screen writers to rely on special effects rather than actual plotting.

If we are talking about watchability, Mr. Deeds (the Sandler version) is right up there too.
Click to expand...

Haven't seen that one yet, I'll have to add it to my list. I loved Happy Gilmore, but most other Sandler movies are just "Meh" to me.
 
Many of those previously mentioned, and also:

Ruthless People
Edward Scissorhands
Bringing Up Baby
 
Most of the films you listed above were comedies for the whole family. For the most part these days Hollywood makes 2 types of comedies.

"Hard R" Kevin Smith/Seth Rogan type comedies aimed at the 20's/30's crowd.

Light-hearted Pixar/animation comedies aimed at the 8-12 year olds that aren't old enough to go to the movies by themselves so Mom and Dad come along and now you turn one ticket purchased into three.
 
what_about_bob_front_large.jpg


Prob the most perfect movie ever IMNSHO^.
 
colton said:
I just checked out IMDB for Mr. Deeds... 5.8/10. Maybe I won't add it to my "to watch" list after all. (sorry Loggrad)
Click to expand...

Yeah, to each their own, but I thought it was pretty bad even when it came out and I was a 14 yr old Adam Sandler fan at the time.

Maybe log means the Mr Deeds movie from 1936?? Never heard of it til I just googled.
 
candrew said:
Most of the films you listed above were comedies for the whole family. For the most part these days Hollywood makes 2 types of comedies.

"Hard R" Kevin Smith/Seth Rogan type comedies aimed at the 20's/30's crowd.

Light-hearted Pixar/animation comedies aimed at the 8-12 year olds that aren't old enough to go to the movies by themselves so Mom and Dad come along and now you turn one ticket purchased into three.
Click to expand...

Yes, the death of good, intelligent comedies has not gone unnoticed by me.
 
colton said:
Excellent! Yes, that is a Perfect Movie in my opinion as well.
Click to expand...

Then we shall remain friends.

Every family seems to have their "family movie" that they watch over and over, and growing up What About Bob? was my family's go to movie for sure. Seen it hundreds of times.

Proby the second most watched movie in my family growing up was the original Parent Trap. Dunno how it holds up now, but watched it all the time when I was a kid.
 
My favorite list would have:

Braveheart (Favorite movie ever, has everything. Love, loyalty, revenge, war, power of the spirit, political intrigue, supressed desires, history...)
Shrek 1 & 2
Lion King
Toy Story 1 & 2
Lock Stock and 2 Smoking Barrells (awesome, awesome movie)
The Notebook (a good chick flick is good stuff, Just damn hard ot make one imo)
Aliens
Predator
Liar Liar
Raiders of The Lost Ark
Dark Knight 1 & 2
 
UGLI baby said:
I HATE the "Hard R" gross out type movie genre.
Click to expand...

I absolutely agree,

Hills have eyes, Saw 1-1,000, Hostel...never seen any of them and I never will.

Same with over the top horror movies. Like all these posession/poltergiest ones.
 
colton said:
I caught the ending of The Princess Bride with my 16 year old daughter a day or two ago. We've of course seen it before, but were drawn in on a TV showing just before they stormed the castle. When it got over, my daughter said something like, "Why don't they make perfect movies any more?" I asked her what she meant, and she explained that most of her very favorite movies--ones that were done just perfectly in her estimation--tended to be from the 80s or 90s. That, combined with the recent Harold Ramis thread got me wondering--what are the perfect movies, movies which in my opinion accomplished their mission to the utmost extent and are a pleasure to watch over and over? Ones like the Princess Bride that I would probably not be able to turn away from were I to catch them playing on TV half way through. As a counter-example, I recently watched Frozen and while it was a great movie it clearly had a couple of problems in the storyline. The answer to this question will vary person by person, but I started making my own list.

(in alphabetical order)
Amadeus
Arsenic and Old Lace
Back to the Future
A Christmas Story
Groundhog Day
Mary Poppins
Men in Black
Monty Python and the Holy Grail
The Princess Bride
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Shrek
Star Wars (episode 4)
Strictly Ballroom

I could probably figure out a few others to include, but that's a good start. Anyone want to dispute my choices, or add to the list? (My own tastes clearly run to the PG variety.)
Click to expand...

It's not my actual favorite movie ever (top 10 for sure), but if I had to name the most perfect movie of all time, I'd probly have to go with Back to the Future.
 
Stoked said:
My favorite list would have:

Braveheart (Favorite movie ever, has everything. Love, loyalty, revenge, war, power of the spirit, political intrigue, supressed desires, history...)
Shrek 1 & 2
Lion King
Toy Story 1 & 2
Lock Stock and 2 Smoking Barrells (awesome, awesome movie)
The Notebook (a good chick flick is good stuff, Just damn hard ot make one imo)
Aliens
Predator
Liar Liar
Raiders of The Lost Ark
Dark Knight 1 & 2
Click to expand...

Agree with Lock Stock.
 
Stoked said:
I absolutely agree,

Hills have eyes, Saw 1-1,000, Hostel...never seen any of them and I never will.

Same with over the top horror movies. Like all these posession/poltergiest ones.
Click to expand...

I hate movies like that too, and actually hate all horror movies, but I biffed my post lol. I meant to specifically point out my hatred for the hard R gross out comedy movie genre. Movie makers just seeing who can throw out the most filth possible, and each year they have to up the ante. Super lazy film making, but I guess most of society likes it.
 
Stoked said:
My favorite list would have:

Braveheart (Favorite movie ever, has everything. Love, loyalty, revenge, war, power of the spirit, political intrigue, supressed desires, history...)
Shrek 1 & 2
Lion King
Toy Story 1 & 2
Lock Stock and 2 Smoking Barrells (awesome, awesome movie)
The Notebook (a good chick flick is good stuff, Just damn hard ot make one imo)
Aliens
Predator
Liar Liar
Raiders of The Lost Ark
Dark Knight 1 & 2
Click to expand...

I haven't seen Braveheart yet, I'll add it to my list of movies to watch (edited version, probably). Lock Stock is already on my list to watch some day (edited...).

I agree that Toy Story 1 and 2 are perfect movies.

Probably won't watch The Notebook.

The rest of your list are already on my list of Perfect Movies above, or else just barely fall short of Perfect Movies for me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Top