I caught the ending of The Princess Bride with my 16 year old daughter a day or two ago. We've of course seen it before, but were drawn in on a TV showing just before they stormed the castle. When it got over, my daughter said something like, "Why don't they make perfect movies any more?" I asked her what she meant, and she explained that most of her very favorite movies--ones that were done just perfectly in her estimation--tended to be from the 80s or 90s. That, combined with the recent Harold Ramis thread got me wondering--what are the perfect movies, movies which in my opinion accomplished their mission to the utmost extent and are a pleasure to watch over and over? Ones like the Princess Bride that I would probably not be able to turn away from were I to catch them playing on TV half way through. As a counter-example, I recently watched Frozen and while it was a great movie it clearly had a couple of problems in the storyline. The answer to this question will vary person by person, but I started making my own list.
(in alphabetical order)
Amadeus
Arsenic and Old Lace
Back to the Future
A Christmas Story
Groundhog Day
Mary Poppins
Men in Black
Monty Python and the Holy Grail
The Princess Bride
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Shrek
Star Wars (episode 4)
Strictly Ballroom
I could probably figure out a few others to include, but that's a good start. Anyone want to dispute my choices, or add to the list? (My own tastes clearly run to the PG variety.)