Knight's work out video with Kings

[utahjazz107]

Wow it was 1.1 huge difference. Harris his junior year averaged 4.4 while Knight averaged 4.2 his freshman year. Harris averaged 1.8 his freshman year...I love how you guys compare Harris and Knight's stats in college and say well He can't be better than him because of his college stats. Not true at all

 

[somebody]

I love how you guys compare Harris and Knight's stats in college and say well He can't be better than him because of his college stats.

I have never said this.

 

[utahjazz107]

Holiday is a 14 and 6.5 player in his 2nd year in the NBA. That's actually really flattering

 

[utahjazz107]

I have never said this.

I'm talking about the majority of people in this thread.

 

[Zerol]

I was responding to Zerol's claim that "Knight is already a much better shooter than Harris." That's why.


Comparing their freshman stats, Knight averaged twice as many turnovers, half as many steals, a third as many blocks, and fewer points-per-shot. He also had a lesser Offensive Rating, Effective FG%, True FG%, and FT rate (that is, Devin got to the free throw line more often per shot attempt).

I don't believe that constitutes being "better than Harris in every single category."

I didn't base my statement on stats, but on the games I watched. Harris is not being respected as a shooter in the NBA (although I think he improved towards the end of the season).

Knight also attempted many more 3 point shots than Harris in college.

 

[utahjazz107]

It's like if someone has the same stats and physical dimensions as another NBA player that means they will be the same type of player in the NBA. Devin Harris would be a great player if he was injury prone or inconsistent. Knight has proven to be neither. He led Kentucky to a deep NCAA run something that Harris didn't do his freshman year..

 

[somebody]

I didn't base my statement on stats, but on the games I watched. Harris is not being respected as a shooter in the NBA (although I think he improved towards the end of the season).

Are you saying that opponents are more closely defending (respecting) Knight than they are Harris, and that Knight, I presume, would have discernibly superior percentages under equal defensive circumstances?

That's an interesting claim, but I would suggest that the NBA provides noticeably tougher defensive circumstances all around, and that Devin Harris still manages to shoot as good a percentage as Knight under rigorous NBA circumstances (and perhaps even better, considering that the NBA FG% extends beyond the college 3-line).

And I would also point out that Devin Harris goes to the free throw line far more frequently than Knight (more per minute, and per shot attempt). While that is by no means definitive, it would not be a stretch to imagine that fouls are committed by close defenders (ie, respect), and that Devin Harris gets far more of that kind of defensive respect than Brandon Knight.

In view of these things, I am still confused by your statement that Brandon Knight is "already a much better shooter than Harris." It's a very strong claim that just doesn't seem to be the case, but I could be wrong.

Knight also attempted many more 3 point shots than Harris in college.

I don't see how this relates. Both shot enough college 3s to provide reliable samples.

 

[billyshelby]

I don't think Knight/Harris college comparisons are going to be very telling, anyway. Unless I'm mistaken, Wisconsin ran one of those Princeton style offenses. But I'm too lazy to look it up, that's just my memory.

 

[Saint Cy of JFC]

Holiday is a 14 and 6.5 player in his 2nd year in the NBA. That's actually really flattering

This, not to mention he is on a team that is littered with guards who can only play with the ball in their hands.

 

[vslice02]

I don't think Knight/Harris college comparisons are going to be very telling, anyway. Unless I'm mistaken, Wisconsin ran one of those Princeton style offenses. But I'm too lazy to look it up, that's just my memory.

Half-right. Wisconsin and Bo Ryan run the swing offense but they do alot of UCLA shuffle cuts and play a slower pace halfcourt offense. I completely agree that comparing statistics from 8-10 years ago from a PG running the swing offense in the Big 10 to a freshman PG playing under John Calipari in the SEC isn't going to be very telling.

 

[Archie Moses]

Knight's work out video with Kings

Can finish but dunno if he's a leaper like Westbrook..

I still don't like his jumper...

Obviously I'm not an expert in it, it's just the release seems a bit rush and as Locke has said, he seems to bring the ball low and come up with it which I don't think helps with accuracy. Also it seems to be block prone to me..

Dunno, what do you guys think?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wo3-0AvfiQk

I'm warming on Knight. He's got great form on his jump shot, although his 3 looks a bit odd. Doesn't look to use his legs as much as his could with his longer shots.

 

[Joe Bagadonuts]

Devin Harris: 44% FG career, 42.2% FG last season (NBA)
Brandon Knight: 42.3% FG (college)

Devin Harris: 80% FT career, 83% FT last season (NBA)
Brandon Knight: 79% FT (college)

They also shot the same percentage from the college three (37%).

I'm not saying you're wrong, I just don't understand why you would say that Knight is a "much better" shooter. Can you explain?

I thought maybe Knight got better as the season went on, but I checked his last 5 games and he shot 32%. In the 5 games before that he shot 34%. It seems like he got progressively worse.

I know he had some Sundiata Gaines moments, but so did Sundiata Gaines.

Sundiata Gaines had some Sundiata Gaines moments? Are you sure about that? The odds against a guy having a moment that just happened to be named after him have to be astronomical!