Depends on how you define "athletic" and how you define the word "elite"
When people say "athletic" they are often talking about explosiveness, speed, quickness, vertical, etc.
When people say "elite" is that top 5% NBA guard? Top 20%? Top 40%
So you compare him to Westbrook, Mitchell, Exum, Vince Carter, etc, etc, and you say "elite" is top 5% NBA guard, the answer is "no"
But the fact that there is more to athleticism than explosiveness, speed, quickness, vertical, I think may be your point and a good one.