Perhaps, I think I may consider too many 1st overall picks to be disappointments given that you are often hoping for some transformational piece. But the Suns made the finals in like his 2nd season after a drought so disappointment is probably unfair.
No way Ayton is above SGA. Trae is a nightmare to build a team around imo, but hard to say he isn't the 2nd/3rd best player in that draft unless you are really weighting his early season struggles. I would take JJJ as well given his defense and spacing, but his injuries are a concern. And he is much more of a role player than a 1st/2nd option player, but I am really high on Mikal Bridges if I were a GM.