Those two reasons are why I left that school. I transferred up to Utah, got the "Mormon" experience without having to pray before I learned about chemical bonds and not worrying about an overzealous institute professor assigning a 10 page report on why Nephi "went and did" and have it screw up my GPA when I decided I was at University to get into grad school, not argue minute points in Sunday School.
I've never understood this.
Maybe someone could shed some light on this? Why do these classes count towards your GPA? And why do they feel like arguing such ridiculous points? Like... Why Nephites saw and did... Or what forms of mental illness did Laman and Lemuel display? To me, this is toxic.
#1 the BOM was never meant to be used as a textbook. Hence, why many details and histories about I their lives are left out. It focuses rather, on their teachings of Christ and his Atonement.
#2 Trying to examine a book that was never intended for scientific examination leads to gross assumptions. This can prove to have a negative effect rather than a positive one. Perhaps that is why we here in Utah have so many people predicting the 2nd coming and why x people haven't received the priesthood yet don't understand the basic principles of the gospel. Nearly every year a general authority must warn about false revelation and incorrect assumptions. I can't help but wonder if (over examining sacred documents) which leads to a lot of assumption leads to incorrect "revelation."
#3 Hurts the perception of science. Those involved in real science actually must dig in find and test evidence. Those doing a research project on Nephi pull stuff out of their rear and roll with it. As a result, I think many people's perception of science then becomes just that. Pulling stuff out of your rear.
Now I recognize the irony of this post. I have no evidence of what I just posted. I'm essentially pulling stuff out of my rear too. I just don't feel like these classes should count towards your GPA. Nor do I feel like they need to be as deep as they make them out to be. One cannot perform a scientific study of a 2,000 year old person whose entire history is depicted on a few pages meant for spiritual enlightenment.
It's the same reason why speculating on Christ's "marriage" or whether he ever had children is ridiculous. The Bible wasn't meant to be a history guide. Or to be a scientific study. But to teach folks about some of Christ's basic teachings.