What's new
By:

All-Time NBA Draft: Round One--spycam1 vs. QuinSnydersHair

Who wins, Spycam1 or QuinSnydersHair?

  • spycam1

    Votes: 29 60.4%

  • QuinSnydersHair

    Votes: 19 39.6%
  • Total voters
    48
  • Poll closed .
Pg: spy (1)
SG:Quin (1)
Sf: Quin (2)
Pf: spy (2)
Ç: Quin (3) tough call
Chem: spy (3) Quins lack of true pg.
Mix:Quin (4)

Quin gets my vote.
 
To me this is spy superior starting lineup vs quin depth.

Fwiw my voting will break down as follows:

I will compare each player at each position and give a point for each player I deem superior.... Then add up the points. (Not even gonna really consider the 3rd stringers tbh)

Then I will look at chemistry/style of play comparisons.

Finally, I will look at which team I would enjoy watching more (the homer portion of my vote.
 
fishonjazz said:
To me this is spy superior starting lineup vs quin depth.

Fwiw my voting will break down as follows:

I will compare each player at each position and give a point for each player I deem superior.... Then add up the points. (Not even gonna really consider the 3rd stringers tbh)

Then I will look at chemistry/style of play comparisons.

Finally, I will look at which team I would enjoy watching more (the homer portion of my vote.
Click to expand...

Wow. That is a lot to consider fosho fisho.
 
I came away with 5-5 on the player comparison lol.

Chemistry and likeability pretty even too.

I see spys team controlling tempo and being too good in the half court of a playoff style game.

Also, starters are more important, and play more minutes than benches and I think spy has the better starting lineup (though depth goes to quin) so I'm leaning spy right now.

Not gonna vote quite yet though
 
fishonjazz said:
To me this is spy superior starting lineup vs quin depth.

Fwiw my voting will break down as follows:

I will compare each player at each position and give a point for each player I deem superior.... Then add up the points. (Not even gonna really consider the 3rd stringers tbh)

Then I will look at chemistry/style of play comparisons.

Finally, I will look at which team I would enjoy watching more (the homer portion of my vote.
Click to expand...

Not everyone is better than everyone by the same amount, though.

What I mean is, if you do exactly what you're saying, then a lineup of Magic + Fesenko would get just as many points as Stockton + David Robinson.
 
spycam1 said:
Not everyone is better than everyone by the same amount, though.

What I mean is, if you do exactly what you're saying, then a lineup of Magic + Fesenko would get just as many points as Stockton + David Robinson.
Click to expand...

Don't worry bro, I already took that into consideration.

It's not each winner matchup gets 1 point necessarily.

If I think one player is a lot better than the other then it's a 2-0 score (kinda like in boxing where if one dude dominates a round then it's a 10-8 round)

Dont think you have to worry about any situations as lopsided as the scenario you presented doe.
Pretty much every player in this tournament is way better than fess and most every player matchup will be pretty close
 
spycam1 said:
Paul Pierce was/is clutch as hell too.
Click to expand...

Worthy.

Also, your Shaq played better comp than Wilt is silly. Wilt played Russell and Kareem in their primes. Shaq's rings were against three mediocre teams in Indy, the Nets, and the Sixers. And Shaq's peak years were when Hakeem, Robinson and Ewing were all in the worst part of their careers.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page
Back
Top