This type of reasoning makes me want to pull every hair out of my head. Why has society given up on win-win...
No **** the best of best will rise to the top, but why do these teachers have to get so ideologically black and white about it? Why is everyone so obsessed with creating a degradative atmosphere that's horrible for everyone?
I'm compulsive..
I don't think the teacher meant any harm by it though. It made the student think which is the main thing. The fact that GF listened to it, thought about it, and formed an opinion different to the teacher, to me, is a success story.