The 10% was a placeholder number… any assigned percentage is completely subjective guesswork… but in one scenario you get almost a total loss and in the other you get a slight bump up.
The Rudy scenario is not comparable at all. We always knew where Rudy stood… he said he wanted to be here… he was willing to be coached hard and wasn’t trying to gain power in the organization. We had every reason to believe he would stay long term if we made reasonable progress. With Donovan we could make great progress and still have him bounce… basically I think you have to make the western conference finals to have a chance… I have no reason to believe we are anywhere near that after the Rudy trade.
If you think we shouldn’t consider trading Donovan as realistic then keeping him and making sound moves for the franchise is equally unrealistic… Royce was off the trade block this deadline for fear of pissing off donovan… Rudy is on the trade block… so does it sound like we are gonna make good moves? Every move will be with Donovan in mind… if we are talking unrealistic scenarios I prefer the one where we move everyone… it’s much better than what is coming.
There's a sliding scale on both ends. You can't take the slight improvement one end and only compare that to the total loss disaster scenario on the negative end. There's a lot of scenarios on either end of differing impact.
We had no reason to believe we could be a good team when Hayward left either. It is different because Rudy was more likely to stay, but Donovan is also under contract for a long time and can't leave even if he wanted to. Rudy would have prevented us from possibly tanking at all, and that seems to be the main motivation here. But the point I was making is that the return from the Gobert trade is not the only reason it could be good to wait. There are several ways it could turn out positive to be more patient.
On the last point, exactly. My scenario where we make sound moves is unrealistic, and so is your scenario where we trade Rudy for Donovan and then proceed to trade Donovan himself. If you're arguing your plan against what will actually happen, I'm right there with you. But I still believe that given the ability to make decisions, I would be more patient with Don trade and have less urgency to tank.